News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys
Clear
36°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Homeless Youth In Crisis
Hot Toys

'It’s poisoning us all.' Residents voice concerns about Brookhaven landfill

The town of Brookhaven and the DEC have been monitoring the plume for years.

Jenna Rae Gaertner

•

Mar 27, 2026, 10:14 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Brookhaven residents are frustrated after a town meeting to discuss corrective measures for the Brookhaven Landfill and the contamination plume spreading underground.

The town of Brookhaven and the DEC have been monitoring the plume for years.

They completed an investigation in 2024, looking into the chemicals seeping into the ground. On Friday, the board presented ways to address the issue.

“The plumes have to be cleaned up and the landfill closed because it’s poisoning us all,” said Laura Lesch, of South Setauket.

During the meeting, the Brookhaven town board presented five alternatives to address the plume: immediate landfill closure, landfill reclamation, groundwater extraction and treatment, enhanced long-term monitoring and additional residential municipal water connections.

Town board members say closing the landfill immediately or completing a waste removal or water treatment project would be time consuming, costly and could add even more toxins and chemicals to the environment. The town ultimately recommended a long-term monitoring system and the eventual closure of the landfill in 2029. They also want all homeowners near the plume to get connected to public water instead of using wells.

“The most important thing is to stop this toxic plume before it enters into Beaver Creek and eventually Bellport Bay,” said Adrienne Esposito, executive director of Citizens Campaign for the Environment.

The board held a listening session after the presentation. Residents came eager to have their voices heard, but left angry and unhappy with the options.

“The reason why it’s a historic plume is because you haven’t done anything about it,” said Monique Fitzgerald, co-founder of Brookhaven Landfill Action and Remediation Group.

While the options presented may stop future contamination, residents say it doesn’t do anything to clean up the current mess.

Public comments will be open through April 7.

Top Stories

01:28
li10pmwesthempsteadgundaniella_2026-11-17-22-11-54

West Hempstead school officials outline new safety measures, task force after student brought gun to campus

01:44
CX Headlines 4 (43)

Sunshine and warmer temperatures continue across Long Island this week

01:08
li10pmantoinettehuntingtonbudget_2026-11-17-22-19-21

Town of Huntington fails to pass 18% tax increase

01:27
li5pmboldaniella_2026-11-17-17-14-55

Apple outages prompt warnings from tech experts on digital vulnerability

00:21
Police-involved shooting

Suffolk police shoot at man they say pointed BB gun at them in Farmingville

00:40
LI 5PM TUES_North Bayshore man guilty_ajc_2026-11-17-17-51-06

North Bay Shore man admits to raping 12-year-old girl, faces up to life in prison

00:18
li10pmbol9yearoldcarhit_2026-11-17-22-12-07

9-year-old hit by car seriously injured in West Babylon

01:29
5PM LI_Travel Troubles_ajc_2026-11-17-17-09-48

Holiday travel concerns grow because of disruptions as Thanksgiving rush approaches

00:26
LIteacherkilledkk_2026-11-17-17-16-02

2 men found guilty of murdering Bronx teacher they mistook for rival gang member

00:19
Stolen Tylenol MS 111726_2026-11-17-17-16-48

Suffolk police seeking 2 men who stole more than $1K worth of Tylenol from Huntington Station pharmacy

SCHOOL STABBING

Sachem East high schooler indicted for stabbing other student

download (1)

Classified communications network at the National Security Agency goes down, defense official says

903015590 18653094049052408 2903697968352615770 n

Rescued seal pup named Guppy returned to ocean after full recovery

02:09
Luke Albert

 Scholar Athlete: Luke Albert, Lindenhurst HS

01:42
Rob Free

LIRR President Rob Free reflects on career ahead of retirement

01:46
Macys Float TN

Eight new floats to debut as Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade celebrates 100 years

00:41
LImassiveexplosionkk_2026-11-17-12-14-19

'Massive explosion' prevented after suspected tampering of propane tanks in Riverhead

00:51
LIupdatedmemorialkk_2026-11-17-17-23-37

Nassau County unveils new memorial honoring officers lost to suicide in Mineola

00:51
LInews12exhibitkk_2026-11-17-12-26-14_12-08-44,20

Behind the desk: Long Island Children's Museum unveils updated News 12 Communication Station

appleJG_2024-03-22-07-28-17

Apple Music, App Store experiencing outages; some iCloud users reporting issues

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices