News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections
Clear
61°
Local
Crime
Weather
Taxing Long Island
Vote 2026: Long Island elections

Body of 1 of 2 missing kayakers recovered in Shinnecock Bay

Two kayaks were found in the Marsh early Sunday morning.

Bob Doda

and

Roberto Torres

•

Nov 2, 2025, 10:08 PM

•

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Southampton police say they recovered the body of one of the two kayakers who had gone missing Saturday in Shinnecock Bay.

According to a release by the police department, the body of 27-year-old Shane Garcia was found after New York State Police and the Southampton Town Marine Patrol Units had located "an area of interest" during their search on Sunday.

The search for the second missing kayaker, Aaron Montemarano, will resume early Monday morning, the department said.

Garcia was reported missing by his girlfriend “who stated he had gone kayaking earlier in the day and had not returned.”

Officers found his work van parked at the end of Shinnecock Avenue in Hampton Bays.

According to an earlier release by Southampton police:

“Mr. Garcia sent a picture to his girlfriend of himself and his friend Aaron Montemarano while kayaking in Shinnecock Bay near Ponquogue Bridge. A search of Shinnecock Bay and the surrounding area yielded negative results...Mr. Montemarano is believed to have been in the company of Mr. Garcia at the time he went missing.”

A U.S. Coast Guard boat crew actively searched the area on Sunday with partner agencies.

“It was reported that local responders located two kayaks and a debris field in the marsh area earlier this morning,” a Coast Guard spokesperson said in a statement to News 12.

Anyone with information is urged to call Southampton Town Police Department Detective Division at 631-728-3400 or the tip hotline at 631-728-3454 | crimetips@southamptontownny.gov.

Top Stories

01:43
5PMarsonchargekk_2026-10-22-17-08-40

Lakeview man accused of trying to set fire to West Hempstead synagogue

02:22
F P1 PM 1

Beautiful, breezy evening on Long Island ahead of cool, dry weather into the weekend

01:29
5PM LI_Opening Statements_ajc_2026-10-22-17-09-23

Trial begins for alleged gang members accused of killing woman in Hempstead 

01:26
Water Hike MS 102226_2026-10-22-17-10-40

Liberty Water rate hike proposal draws opposition from local officials

00:50
5PM LI_Teacher Stalking_ajc_2026-10-22-17-06-26

Valley Stream teaching assistant accused of stalking student

00:19
ssp crash

Driver suffers medical emergency, hits 10 vehicles on Southern State

00:27
d7f98425-de2a-4319-82ef-df0de5bc4764

Indictment alleges Glen Cove woman kept daughters, 166 cats in filthy home with high ammonia levels

00:31
Shark Fin Generic

Long Island man accused of illegal capture of great white shark off Cape Cod

02:03
IMG 6200

Library in Mastic Beach shortens hours over safety and security fears

00:27
LIreligouszoningkk_2026-10-22-13-08-14

Village of Atlantic Beach changing zoning rules following federal settlement

00:50
1022babynames_2026-10-22-09-36-17

BabyCenter: 5 boy names top popularity list for third consecutive year

00:18
1022garbagefire_2026-10-22-07-33-36

Lithium-ion battery sparks garbage fire in Rockville Centre

00:23
ralph's

Great Neck Ralph’s Italian Ices to stay open all year long

01:38
1022richriverhead_2026-10-22-05-47-28

Riverhead supervisor race pits incumbent Halpin against challenger Rothwell

00:20
1022hochulgunsafety_subclip_subclip_2026-10-22-05-33-15_05-08-31,16

Hochul signs legislation to expand firearm storage rules, prevent prohibited ammo purchases

01:39
1022taxingLI_2026-10-22-05-42-23

Taxing Long Island: Volunteer firefighter tax credit will make 'a little difference,' more incentives needed

01:37
1022liroadtrip_2026-10-22-05-27-45

Road Trip Close to Home: Race Hub STEM Activity Center & Raceway

01:03
1022eastend_2026-10-22-05-35-02

The East End: Long Island Doll Hospital

01:36
LI 10PM WED_Saving Historic House_ajc_2026-10-21-22-15-34_22-08-41,04

Descendants fight to save historic 150-year-old Lucy Keyes home in Setauket

Pirro

Exclusive: Jeanine Pirro on national security, crime and her high-profile Washington role

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices