News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Stony Brook Medicine

Middletown restaurant allowed to serve liquor after 100-year-old law overturned

It is due to a law dating back to 1918, even before Prohibition banned businesses within 200 feet of a church from selling hard liquor.

Stephen O'Leary

Sep 17, 2025, 5:36 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

For nearly two decades, Juan Avalos has been serving tacos at his restaurant, Taco Factory, without the one thing many customers crave alongside their meal: tequila.

It is due to a law dating back to 1918, even before Prohibition banned businesses within 200 feet of a church from selling hard liquor.

That restriction kept Avalos and two other downtown Middletown restaurants from offering spirits, even as other nearby establishments were allowed to serve alcohol.

“It’s a 1918 law that nothing can open next to a church,” Avalos explained. “I cannot get them to stay based on a wine product. They want the real thing — they want the tequila.”

Avalos tried alternatives like agave wine, but says customers weren’t interested.

“This is our agave wine,” he said, holding up a bottle. “But people aren’t buying it literally.”

Now, thanks to a newly signed law by Gov. Kathy Hochul, that was introduced as a bill by Sen. James Skoufis, Avalos and the other affected businesses will finally be allowed to apply for a liquor license.

“We’re not trying to derail society,” Avalos said. “We’re just trying to pair liquor with our food.”

Avalos says it will be a game changer, not just for his business, but for the local economy.

“It will create more jobs. I’ll hire a full-time bartender and full-time wait staff.”

To move forward, Avalos needed a letter of support from the neighboring church, which he received, and approval from both the state and city planning board. He says both have already given him the green light.

“Once we get the liquor license, things will change — not only for downtown, but for my business as well.”

For now, the law applies only to Middletown, but officials say it could expand to other parts of New York state in the future.

More Stories

Top Stories

02:13
LIRRALERT2SHOT52926_2026-05-29-08-34-09

LIRR delays and cancellations persist after service restored to Penn Station following Amtrak-related fire

02:56
F P1 PM 1(216)

Warm today, but chilly winds on Saturday for Long Island

03:05
LIDRNACHMAN52926_2026-05-29-07-08-46

Tips to stay safe from ticks this summer

02:24
LIFOODTRUCK52926_2026-05-29-07-08-50

Food Truck Friday: Iron Chef Catering on wheels

APnewstn

Judge temporarily blocks payouts from Trump’s $1.8B ‘anti-weaponization’ settlement fund

00:24
LIWOODMEREAXARREST529_2026-05-29-05-41-35

Driver arrested two months after fatal Woodmere crash

01:10
EASTENDSPLISHSPLASH52926_2026-05-29-08-59-50

Cooling off from the summer heat with some fun at Splish Splash water park

00:29
LIBAYARD52926_2026-05-29-06-24-34

A plant sale is happening this weekend at Bayard Cutting

00:29
hit and run arrest

Man arrested for hit-and-run, drug possession in Suffolk

00:37
LIMCLEAN529_2026-05-29-05-59-52

Mets pitcher Nolan McLean teaches little leaguers at Nassau clinic

01:51
LILogan5pmStudentDeadKK_2026-05-28-17-37-41

Sag Harbor community mourns 6th grader who drowned in rafting accident on school trip

01:53
5-28-26 Bayville Attack

2 teens charged for menacing and attacking drivers in Bayville

01:47
LI 5PM THU_Data Center Concerns_ajc_2026-05-28-17-05-38

Town supervisor says no data centers are coming to Brookhaven

01:37
MP Ticks MS 052826_2026-05-28-17-09-09

Miller Place parents raise concerns over ticks at schools amid spike in tick activity on LI

00:20
Screenshot 2026-05-28 115804

Deer Park woman that used dynamite to blow off her boyfriend's hand sentenced to 18 years in prison

00:21
LILBStrollerKidnappingKK_2026-05-28-18-31-12

Long Beach woman indicted for trying to grab toddler from stroller

00:42
LIhurricane528_2026-05-28-12-15-48

Red Cross, PSEGLI urge Long Islanders to prepare for hurricane season as flood risks rise

Traffic Generic

LIE lanes reopened at Exit 44 following overturned car carrier

00:25
LISHAKESHACK528_2026-05-28-05-35-19

Shake Shack to open first East End location this summer

01:44
LIhalloffame528_2026-05-28-12-27-56

Music, television and entertainment at the Long Island Music and Entertainment Hall of Fame

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices