News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Partly Cloudy
76°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

Suffolk DA: Law enforcement had to be cautious with info about case prior to Heuermann's arrest

The district attorney says authorities were getting closer and closer over the past 18 months to making a break in the Gilgo investigation, but they could not let the suspect know that.

Rich Barrabi

Jul 24, 2023, 6:14 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney says law enforcement had to communicate with the public very carefully prior to the arrest of Rex Heuermann.

LIVE BLOG: Gilgo Beach Murders

The district attorney says authorities were getting closer and closer over the past 18 months to making a break in the Gilgo investigation, but they could not let the suspect know that.

MORE: Gilgo murders: Suffolk police commissioner says investigators took numerous items from Heuermann's home


"I wanted him to be safe in the belief that we were not making progress," Tierney says.

WATCH: DOCUMENTARY AND BACKGROUND INFORMATION - Gilgo Beach: Unsolved

He says as progress continued to be made, investigators feared that details about the investigation could leak.

MORE: Gilgo Beach investigation takes major turn as police search suspect's backyard

"We want to execute search warrants, and we want to get even more evidence," Tierney says. "And if this becomes public, all of that goes up in smoke."

Top Stories

02:07
dji mimo 20260917 071932 20260917071933 1789644024887 photo

Costco limits motor oil purchases as oil, gas prices continue to soar

02:02
F P2 PM 1 1

Changes going into the weekend with rain that will impact your weekend plans

00:19
SOUTHAMPTON THEFT

Police search for women who stole camera equipment from Southampton hotel

00:32
917farmreopens_2026-09-17-07-42-46

Crescent Duck Farm in Aquebogue reopens nearly 2 years after bird flu outbreak

00:27
pizzeria crash

Car smashes through glass window of Rockville Centre pizzeria

00:17
917hitandrunguiltyplea_2026-09-17-07-09-22

Southampton man pleads guilty to leaving scene of crash killing 67-year-old pedestrian

00:24
LIASSAULTDISMISSED917_2026-09-17-05-45-28

Assault charge against Smithtown councilman dismissed

01:15
alexfallfoliage

Fall foliage outlook 2026: More color than last year, but will it be worth a road trip?

01:44
917rockclimbing_2026-09-17-05-33-07

Go on a rock-climbing adventure at the Gravity Vault

01:06
917eastend_2026-09-17-05-58-00

The East End: East End Surf Club in Montauk

01:19
917taxingli_2026-09-17-05-41-09

You could have unclaimed cash sitting with NY state. Here's how to find it.

01:43
LI 10PM WED_South Country Probs_ajc_2026-09-16-22-16-09

'We need solutions.' Parents press Bellport school leaders over safety concerns

02:05
IMG 6045

South Shore residents call for traffic relief at Mastic community meeting

00:21
LI 10PM WED_Fire Island Fire_ajc_2026-09-16-22-15-36_22-03-33,26

Fire destroys home in Fire Island Pines; cause remains under investigation

Flock Part 1 MS 081726_2026-08-17-17-18-23

Suffolk County delays contract with Flock, extends deal with ShotSpotter

01:38
Gambling Issues MS 091626_2026-09-16-17-41-49

Mobile sports betting becomes NY's No. 2 gaming revenue source as problem gambling calls rise

01:49
Egg Donation MS 091626_2026-09-16-17-38-33

Long Island food banks receive 972,000 eggs through settlement, helping families facing food insecurity

01:39
LIReducedRefsKK_2026-09-16-17-52-03

Brentwood students train to become referees amid LI officiating shortage

00:12
UNLAWFUL SURVEILLANCE

Police seek man who put cellphone up woman’s dress in Riverhead

01:34
blaise waldman

Children of NY woman killed in 1974 speak out after advances in DNA, genealogy identify her killer

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices