Taxing Long Island
News12 New York
Download the App
Where to Watch
Local
Crime
Weather
beWell
The East End
Crime Files
Stony Brook Medicine

'I can move on.' Sister of Gilgo victim says she is grateful for some closure

Amber Lynn Costello's body was found on Dec. 13, 2010 on Ocean Parkway during a search for missing person Shannan Gilbert.

Antoinette Biordi

Jul 18, 2023, 5:57 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

The sister of one of the Gilgo Beach murder victims says she is grateful for a break in the case which finally gave her some sort of closure.

Amber Lynn Costello's sister, Kimberly Overstreet, says she misses her sister every day.

GILGO MURDERS: Investigators collecting evidence from accused Gilgo serial killer’s South Carolina property 


Costello was a 27-year-old sex worker living in West Babylon when she was last seen alive in Sept. 2010. That is when police say she met Rex Heuermann who picked her up at her house.

Costello's body was found on Dec. 13, 2010 on Ocean Parkway during a search for missing person Shannan Gilbert.

How police used a revived tip to make break in Gilgo Beach murder investigation

"It brings me peace to know that my sister is laying with my family," Overstreet says. "And that if my parents were here, if my sister was here, she would say 'Thank you, and I forgive him.' I forgive him and she would too. I don't know if it makes a difference to him, but it makes a difference to me, and I can move on."

Overstreet says the arrest also gives her hope that police will be able to give the other victim's families closure at some point.

Car crashes to workers comp: Court records offer glimpse into Gilgo Beach murder suspect's past

More Stories

Top Stories

hijacking

3 accused of gunpoint hijacking of Apple delivery truck at Americana Manhasset

02:16
LI-TODAY

Sunshine returns today; warm up for Mother's Day but rain in the area

00:26
GenericPOLICE

Southampton man posed as ex-partner, canceled Aruba vacation just hours before takeoff

00:31
57expresswaycrashnoon_2026-05-07-12-05-12

Tractor-trailer crash shuts down part of LIE in Plainview

2025 Mom Rocks Logo Adventureland Sponsor 1920x1080

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

00:47
57hochulstatebudget_2026-05-07-12-04-37

Gov. Hochul’s 2027 state budget agreement announcement sparks backlash

00:52
blaise hantavirus

'What's happening right now is very real.' New York man documents life aboard expedition ship tied to hantavirus outbreak

00:24
57officerssavewomannoon_2026-05-07-12-09-35

Officers restore woman’s pulse after fainting episode in Deer Park

00:20
57storerobberyli_2026-05-07-05-33-52

Photos released of men wanted in violent robbery at Holtsville 7-Eleven

01:42
57taxingLI_2026-05-07-05-41-13

Long Island office vacancies fall as workers return and local businesses rebound

00:26
LIFARMSTANDTHEFTS507_2026-05-07-05-37-37

Blue Point farm stand reports items stolen twice in a week

00:25
LIBURGLARYSPREE507_2026-05-07-05-44-46

Queens man arrested for multiple residential burglaries in Nassau County

01:48
57joneasthampton_2026-05-07-06-04-18

East Hampton Town considering law to limit local police's role in federal civil immigration enforcement

01:03
57LIeastend_2026-05-07-12-19-21

Embark on an adventure at East End Fishing Charters

00:44
LISWASTIKA507_2026-05-07-05-05-57

Symbol of hate found etched into window at Inwood LIRR station

01:51
57LIroadtrip_2026-05-07-06-34-49

Shop great deals at the Tri-County Unique Bazaar in Levittown

00:15
motorcyclecrash

Teen motorcyclist seriously injured in Miller Place crash

01:51
Super Resigns MS 050626_2026-05-06-18-04-07

South Country School District superintendent resigns amid myriad of financial issues

01:39
LI 10PM WED_SuperMarketSpirits_ajc_2026-05-06-22-20-19

Convenience or competition? Proposed bill could change where you buy wine and liquor

01:42
LI 10PM WED_MoneyWorries_ajc_2026-05-06-22-09-02

Nearly 70% of Americans fear running out of money more than death, new study finds

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices