NY lawsuit against gay marriage thrown out

(AP) - A Bronx judge has thrown out the first direct legal challenge to Gov. David Paterson's move to recognize out-of-state gay marriages. In a ruling Tuesday, state Supreme Court Judge Lucy Billings

News 12 Staff

Sep 2, 2008, 8:40 PM

Updated 5,804 days ago

Share:

(AP) - A Bronx judge has thrown out the first direct legal challenge to Gov. David Paterson's move to recognize out-of-state gay marriages.
In a ruling Tuesday, state Supreme Court Judge Lucy Billings said the policy is a "permissible, if not mandated, step toward the objective of equality" for gays. Her finding comes as thousands of gay New Yorkers are expected to take advantage of a new Massachusetts law letting them wed there.
Paterson's counsel told state agencies in May that a recent appellate court ruling required them to recognize gay marriages legally performed elsewhere.
An Arizona-based Christian legal group, the Alliance Defense Fund, filed a lawsuit saying the issue should be decided by the state Legislature, not the governor.
The alliance and Paterson's office had no immediate response to the ruling.


More from News 12
Southwest breaks with 50-year tradition and will assign seats; profit falls at Southwest, American

Southwest breaks with 50-year tradition and will assign seats; profit falls at Southwest, American

2:29
Mostly cloudy, muggy conditions with a possible stray shower on Long Island

Mostly cloudy, muggy conditions with a possible stray shower on Long Island

0:42
Police: Hempstead woman arrested for DWI with 3-year-old daughter inside vehicle

Police: Hempstead woman arrested for DWI with 3-year-old daughter inside vehicle

1:49
Police: Fire erupts at Elmont home, spreads to neighbor’s garage

Police: Fire erupts at Elmont home, spreads to neighbor’s garage

0:19
Officials: Huntington Station man sentenced to prison for fatally stabbing friend, trying to kill friend’s wife

Officials: Huntington Station man sentenced to prison for fatally stabbing friend, trying to kill friend’s wife

1:51
Enjoy family fun at Empire Adventure Park in Nassau County

Enjoy family fun at Empire Adventure Park in Nassau County

2:06
Best Beaches: Venetian Shores in Lindenhurst

Best Beaches: Venetian Shores in Lindenhurst

3:25
The East End: Someday Came Fishing Charters

The East End: Someday Came Fishing Charters

0:22
Police: 2 suspects wanted for attempting to use stolen credit card in Islandia

Police: 2 suspects wanted for attempting to use stolen credit card in Islandia

0:28
Prosecutors: Former Nassau County Fire Service Academy employee accused of defrauding workers compensation

Prosecutors: Former Nassau County Fire Service Academy employee accused of defrauding workers compensation

2:15
Another man pleads not guilty  in a Nassau County burglary ring that started last summer

Another man pleads not guilty in a Nassau County burglary ring that started last summer

2:00
Wyandanch residents demand answers nearly one year after investigation began into grade fixing allegations

Wyandanch residents demand answers nearly one year after investigation began into grade fixing allegations

0:41
Biden delivers solemn call to defend democracy as he lays out his reasons for quitting race

Biden delivers solemn call to defend democracy as he lays out his reasons for quitting race

0:15
Officials: Car fire in Hicksville spreads to home, no injuries reported

Officials: Car fire in Hicksville spreads to home, no injuries reported

2:13
Police: Fake company 'Top Line Masonry' scammed homeowners in Floral Park

Police: Fake company 'Top Line Masonry' scammed homeowners in Floral Park

0:15
Police: Teen struck by car while riding bike in Rockville Centre

Police: Teen struck by car while riding bike in Rockville Centre

1:16
Two LI natives go for gold at Summer Olympics

Two LI natives go for gold at Summer Olympics

1:56
Nassau Democrats block vote on borrowing until grant money released

Nassau Democrats block vote on borrowing until grant money released

1:43
Bay Shore Assembly of God school's sudden closure leaves parents scrambling

Bay Shore Assembly of God school's sudden closure leaves parents scrambling

2:42
'Gonna save at least one.' Eastport father who lost daughter to cancer turns grief into helping others

'Gonna save at least one.' Eastport father who lost daughter to cancer turns grief into helping others