News12 New York
N12 Originals
Numbers & Links
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island
Clear
72°
Local
Crime
Weather
Politics
Taxing Long Island

Cause of fire that ripped through Hyde Park's historic Crumwold Hall under investigation

Town officials said the fire seems to have started on the ground floor around 8 a.m. Firefighters from at least five departments arrived with every resource available.

Ben Nandy

Jan 1, 2026, 4:59 PM

Updated

Share:

More Stories

A historic mansion in Hyde Park was still burning hours after it caught fire early Thursday morning, displacing 11 residents.

Town officials said the fire seems to have started on the ground floor around 8 a.m. Firefighters from at least five departments arrived with every resource available.

Neighbors of the 74-room, late-1800s house best known as Crumwold Hall told News 12 they woke up Thursday morning to the smell of smoke while they were still in their beds.

The building was turned over to a religious organization, Millennial Kingdom Family Church, in the 1980s.

The property has since been fenced off to the public, with the mansion sitting a few hundred feet off of Mansion Drive.

Firefighters were preparing late Thursday to stay overnight to monitor the scene.

All 11 residents escaped without injuries, the town supervisor said, though one police officer had to pull one of the residents out of a first-floor bathroom to safety.

The Red Cross was on scene to offer temporary accommodations to the residents, neighbors said.

Neighbors who woke up to the smoke and have been smelling it ever since said this disaster especially stings because they are proud of their local history and because the mansion's residents were good neighbors.

"I just feel for them, for the family," neighbor Scott Bernhard." Especially, if you know them, that's what makes this feel just awful."

The cause was still unclear late Thursday.

Forensics experts were not able to enter the home to investigate since it was still burning.

Town Supervisor Al Torreggiani said the town building inspector will visit the home Friday morning. He says that the home will likely be conde

More Stories

Top Stories

7224LISCWALLYCONVICTION10_2024-07-02-22-09-30

Drunk driver who killed 4 in Deer Park salon crash scheduled for sentencing today

01:57
F P1 PM 1

Scattered shower chance overnight ahead of a nice Wednesday on Long Island

00:30
812islipdatacenters_subclip_2026-08-12-05-18-54_05-07-29,22

Town of Islip approves 18-month ban on new data centers

00:23
LIRUNNINGRETURN812_2026-08-12-05-10-57

Sayville Running Company returning to Main Street after 2024 fire

00:22
LINLKNIFEPOINT812_2026-08-12-05-07-31

Man arrested for stealing cellphone at knifepoint in North Lawrence

01:57
li5pmjuliamacmillian_2026-08-11-17-43-00

Baldwin teen sentenced to 20 years to life for deadly shooting outside Hempstead house party

01:48
li10pmbol2026zoningboard_2026-08-11-22-09-48

Proposed trucking facility draws concern in Kings Park

01:58
li10pmbolcolombia2026_2026-08-11-22-04-46

Bay Shore woman’s family survives Colombia quake as Long Island community rallies to help

01:33
li10pmbolpawsofwar_2026-08-11-22-29-38

Long Island veterans turn to Paws of War for help while searching for pet friendly homes

01:23
5pmloganfixconstruction_2026-08-11-18-09-28

Accused driver held on $200K bail after fatal Nesconset crash that killed construction worker, injured 2 others

00:30
li5pmgilgoprison_2026-08-11-17-16-30

State confirms prison assignment for Gilgo Beach killer Rex Heuermann

00:28
LI5StabbingPleaKK_2026-08-11-17-06-41

North Carolina man admits killing girlfriend's ex-boyfriend outside Stony Brook Yacht Club

Gotti Arrest MS 060426_2026-06-04-17-11-28

Gotti's grandson surrenders himself into federal custody

02:29
1000049309

Westbury homeowner pleads for help after tree crashes through her home, trapping dozens of cats inside

00:42
LIAIAdsBlakemanKK_2026-08-11-12-16-53

State Democratic chair files complaint against Blakeman over AI campaign ads

00:28
LIIslandersJerseyKK_2026-08-11-12-16-33

Islanders narrow over 80,000 third jersey submissions to final 8

01:58
LITAXINGLIHOUSE81126_2026-08-11-05-56-32

Over 130,000 people moved out of New York last year. Why?

00:28
dwi arrest

Police: Man arrested after damaging Hampton Bays property during DWI crash

00:44
Screenshot 2026-08-11 053649

Gov. Hochul warns Medicare changes could increase prescription drug costs for 1.3 million New Yorkers

00:39
LIHOPSITALLAWSUIT811_2026-08-11-05-11-05

North Shore University Hospital facing lawsuit for alleged unpaid fees

App StoreGoogle Play Store

info

Newsletter

Send Photos/Videos

Contact

About Us

News Team

News 12 New York

follow us

Twitter

Facebook

Instagram

more resources

Optimum Corporate

Optimum Service

Advertise on News 12

Careers

Content Removal Policy

© 2026 N12N, LLC

Privacy Policy

Terms of Service

Ad Choices