End of an era: A Century-old New Jersey taxidermy business now at a crossroads

As New Jersey has become less rural over the years, it has led to a decline in traditions like hunting. And the lack of hunting has led to the decline of another tradition – taxidermy.

News 12 Staff

Jan 21, 2020, 11:52 PM

Updated 1,554 days ago

Share:

As New Jersey has become less rural over the years, it has led to a decline in traditions like hunting. And the lack of hunting has led to the decline of another tradition – taxidermy.
The decline in taxidermy has caused a nearly 100-year-old family business to reconsider how to go forward in the future. Schwendeman Taxidermy in Milltown is a place where hundreds of animals are frozen in place, and the place is frozen in time.
“My grandparents started the business in the front of their house, on the front porch,” says Linda Schwendeman.
Art and Lillian Schwendeman moved their business from their house out back into a shop in the late 1930s. It still contains the old cash register, hundreds of mounts and antlers and tools of the trade for taxidermy. Art and Lillian's granddaughters Mary Ellen Davis and Lillian Schwendeman started cleaning deer antlers for a quarter apiece when they were 7 years old.
Davis and Schwendeman’s father, David Schwendeman, became well known in the taxidermy world, working as the chief taxidermist at New York's Museum of Natural History - a job he had for 27 years.
“It is an art and a science put together,” says Davis
David Lillian Schwendeman died in 2012, the same year that Davis and Schwendeman’s brother Bruce, who was running the Milltown business at the time, had to stop working due to losing his eyesight to diabetes.
Ever since then Schwendeman Taxidermy has pretty much been in limbo while Davis and Schwendeman decide what to do next in a state where taxidermy is not as popular any longer.
“If we could take everything and move it out to Wisconsin, we could make a living,” says Davis.
The sisters say that they have the skills to keep doing taxidermy, but that earning a living in New Jersey doing the practice would be difficult.
“There’s less and less hunting and it’s not paying the bills,” says Davis.
Some of the pieces still in the shop are headed to an environmental education center being built in their grandparent's old log cabin down the road. But the business remains uncertain.
“This is so much a part of who we are and how we grew up. I feel some kind of, no an obligation, but an honor, to do something with it for the good of nature,” Davis says.
The Schwendeman Nature Center in the family's old log cabin is a work in progress. The center will be run by the town of Milltown.


More from News 12
2:21
Town supervisor: 2 women injured in Massapequa crash; public safety vehicle stolen while trying to help

Town supervisor: 2 women injured in Massapequa crash; public safety vehicle stolen while trying to help

1:30
Chance for showers Wednesday; cooldown for the end of the workweek

Chance for showers Wednesday; cooldown for the end of the workweek

2:14
Sachem School Board adopts budget piercing tax cap at 4.87%

Sachem School Board adopts budget piercing tax cap at 4.87%

1:28
Amityville, Sayville School Boards vote not to pierce tax caps

Amityville, Sayville School Boards vote not to pierce tax caps

0:23
Santos bows out of independent run for NY's 1st Congressional District

Santos bows out of independent run for NY's 1st Congressional District

1:48
Police release photos of vehicle involved in 2022 fatal drive-by shooting in Ronkonkoma in hope of leads

Police release photos of vehicle involved in 2022 fatal drive-by shooting in Ronkonkoma in hope of leads

0:23
Police: 5 teens caught on camera trespassing into Patchogue building

Police: 5 teens caught on camera trespassing into Patchogue building

1:40
Remains of 7 WWII vets found at Freeport funeral home

Remains of 7 WWII vets found at Freeport funeral home

0:34
DA: Syosset man pleads guilty in DWI crash that killed married couple in Laurel Hollow

DA: Syosset man pleads guilty in DWI crash that killed married couple in Laurel Hollow

1:57
3 families displaced by fast-moving fire at North Amityville home

3 families displaced by fast-moving fire at North Amityville home

0:51
NCC working with food truck vendors to provide food for rest of semester

NCC working with food truck vendors to provide food for rest of semester

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

1:42
Made on Long Island: Nicolock Paving Stones in Lindenhurst

Made on Long Island: Nicolock Paving Stones in Lindenhurst

0:48
9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

1:54
Ronkonkoma woman pleads not guilty to 49 counts of animal cruelty

Ronkonkoma woman pleads not guilty to 49 counts of animal cruelty

1:33
Hampton Bays woman retrieves phone, wallet she accidently dumped into recycling bin nearly 3 weeks ago

Hampton Bays woman retrieves phone, wallet she accidently dumped into recycling bin nearly 3 weeks ago

0:32
Spartans chosen as new mascot for Brentwood school district

Spartans chosen as new mascot for Brentwood school district

0:19
Police: 2 people hospitalized following Lawrence crash

Police: 2 people hospitalized following Lawrence crash

2:12
Amityville schools to receive $2 million from new state budget to help reduce budget deficit, save jobs

Amityville schools to receive $2 million from new state budget to help reduce budget deficit, save jobs

0:17
Man wanted for stealing $1,000 in merchandise from Centereach store

Man wanted for stealing $1,000 in merchandise from Centereach store