Spota’s attorney: Prosecution took ‘deep dive into an ocean of speculation’

Posted: Updated:

A jury is now deciding the fate of the man who was once Suffolk's top prosecutor and his former top aide.

The defense attorney for former Suffolk District Attorney Thomas Spota began his closing arguments Thursday, saying that the prosecution took “a deep dive into an ocean of speculation.”

Spota and his top aide Christopher McPartland are on trial for allegedly helping to conceal former Police Chief James Burke’s assault on a prisoner in 2012.

RELATED: Prosecution focuses on ex-lieutenant’s testimony in Spota trial closing arguments 

Alan Vinegrad, Spota’s attorney, also discredited the government’s star witness, James Hickey - a lieutenant in the Suffolk County Police Department at the time of Christopher Loeb’s beating.

Vinegrad reminded jurors that Hickey admitted he lied on the stand in a separate trial in the 1990s and had four extramarital affairs.

“Bear in mind, Jim Hickey is a man with a long track record of lying when it is in his best interest to lie,” said Vinegrad.

Hickey had testified that he had direct conversations with Spota and McPartland about the alleged cover-up.

During the government's rebuttal, prosecutor Lara Gatz reminded jurors that there are two kinds of evidence – direct and circumstantial. She then put up a list of 23 things she said just doesn’t make sense if Spota and McPartland were not taking part in the cover-up.

She says that list includes items that witnesses, other than Hickey, testified to, such as:

  • James Burke's first call after the Loeb assault was to McPartland
  • There was an emergency meeting at Spota's house in 2013 after the FBI issued subpoenas.
  • Spota called Burke's attorney in 2015 to ask what the feds were investigating.

On Monday, the jury will be charged, or given instructions, by the judge about what they can consider under the law. They should be deliberating by Monday afternoon.

  • SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>

  • Your January 2020 Storm Photos

    Your January 2020 Storm Photos

    Have a great or fun photo during snowstorms in January 2020? We want to see them!
    Have a great or fun photo during snowstorms in January 2020? We want to see them!
  • Dog Day Fridays for Jan. 17

    Dog Day Fridays for Jan. 17

    Friday, January 17 2020 10:01 AM EST2020-01-17 15:01:18 GMT
    Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.
    Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Ruff House Rescue. They brought three puppies!
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Ruff House Rescue. They brought three puppies!
  • It's National Dress Up Your Pet Day - Submit your photos

    It's National Dress Up Your Pet Day - Submit your photos

    Tuesday, January 14 2020 5:36 AM EST2020-01-14 10:36:44 GMT
    Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?
    Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?
    According to the National Retail Federation, Americans were expected to spend $490 million on costumes for their pets this past Halloween. But there's another special day to celebrate your furry friend!
    According to the National Retail Federation, Americans were expected to spend $490 million on costumes for their pets this past Halloween. But there's another special day to celebrate your furry friend!
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."