Prosecution focuses on ex-lieutenant’s testimony in Spota trial closing arguments

Posted: Updated:

The prosecution started its closing arguments in the obstruction trial of former Suffolk County District Attorney Tom Spota and his top investigator Christopher McPartland.

Prosecutor Lara Gatz has spent hours standing in front of a jury trying to summarize her case. The testimony has lasted for weeks so far. Both men are accused of helping cover up the beating of suspect Christopher Loeb by then-Suffolk Police Chief James Burke in 2012.

Gatz focused on the government’s star witness, James Hickey - a lieutenant in the Suffolk County Police Department at the time of Loeb’s beating.

News 12 has reported that Hickey testified he had direct conversations and meetings with Spota and Christopher McPartland about the alleged cover-up. Hickey told the court, "I assumed Spota knew from Burke... because Spota knew. We all knew Burke did it. We were covering it up."

Hickey testified that one meeting took place at Spota’s office.

"Look at the phone traffic,” Gatz told the jury. “They have no legal business in this matter anymore and remember, James Burke doesn't even work with Tom Spota or Christopher McPartland anymore.”

Hickey had also testified that when Burke knew he was going to be arrested, he told him he was "willing to do three years, playing cards with mobsters."

Gatz also accused Emily Constant, one of the government's own witnesses, of lying on the stand during the trial because her testimony contradicted Hickey's. Constant was the second in command in Spota's office and testified she doesn't want to see Spota or McPartland convicted.

When asked if she lied on the stand, she told News 12, “Absolutely not.”

“I would never do that, and I haven't lied in my 38-year career, and I certainly wouldn't pick federal court to start doing it,” said Constant.

The defense had its chance at closing arguments in the afternoon. McPartland's attorney Larry Krantz slammed the prosecution for accusing Constant of perjury. Krantz also tried to discredit Hickey to jurors, saying of McPartland, “The evidence shows that he has been falsely accused by one man, Jim Hickey, who is a combination of desperate and not well."

News 12 reported that Hickey was hospitalized twice – once for excessive drinking and another time for hallucinating. He says the hospitalizations were brought on by the "weight of the conspiracy.”

MORE:
Retired Suffolk lieutenant kept meticulous calendars of Spota, McPartland conversations 
Key witness says he had conversations with Spota, McPartland about Burke cover-up 
Ex-Suffolk detective 'feared for everything' during alleged Spota cover-up 

 

  • SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>

  • Your April 2020 Super Pink Moon Photos

    Your April 2020 Super Pink Moon Photos

    This week's Super Pink Moon is the biggest full moon of 2020. Did you see it? Share your photos with us.
    This week's Super Pink Moon is the biggest full moon of 2020. Did you see it? Share your photos with us.
  • Your Breath of Fresh Air Photos

    Your Breath of Fresh Air Photos

    In these trying times, we can all use a breath of fresh air every once in a while. News 12 wants to see your scenic photos while you get your breath of fresh air.
    In these trying times, we can all use a breath of fresh air every once in a while. News 12 wants to see your scenic photos while you get your breath of fresh air.
  • PHOTOS: The Impact of coronavirus around the world

    PHOTOS: The Impact of coronavirus around the world

    CoronavirusCoronavirus
    CoronavirusCoronavirus
    These photos capture scenes around the world as countries cope with the outbreak.
    These photos capture scenes around the world as countries cope with the outbreak. 
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."