Proposed hotel at Smithtown’s Watermill to get environmental impact study

Posted: Updated:

The Smithtown Town Council voted 5-0 Tuesday in favor of an environmental impact study for a proposed four-story hotel at the site of the Watermill catering venue.

For months, many Smithtown residents have been calling on the council to reject the proposed 130-room hotel – citing pollution, traffic congestion and sewage problems as their main reasons.

"There are a number of potentially significant environmental impacts associated with this proposed hotel," says Russell Barnett, of the Smithtown Environment & Waterways Department.

A memo from the department warned that restaurateur Anthony Scotto's proposal could have significant impacts on groundwater, traffic and sewage treatment.

"The issue is that immediately to the west of this site, there are hundreds of homes in a high groundwater area where their cesspools and septic system are in groundwater,” says Barnett. “Those septic systems create an environmental impact on what is known as the northeast branch of the Nissequogue River.”

Barnett went on to explain that there is a policy decision that needs to be made: Whether to use the sewage treatment plant capacity for a hotel or to remediate the flooded septic systems to the immediate west.

Environmental officials recommended a formal environmental impact study under the state and environmental quality review act, which the Town Council agreed to.

"All of those issues will be taken up by those environmental experts," says Town Supervisor Edward Wehrheim.

Anthony Scotto's attorney told News 12 that they agree with the requirement for an environmental impact statement. He said they will meet all the requirements.

  • NewsMore>>

  • Superintendent: Northport Middle School students to be relocated amid environmental probe

    Superintendent: Northport Middle School students to be relocated amid environmental probe

    Saturday, January 18 2020 6:56 PM EST2020-01-18 23:56:19 GMT
    Students at Northport Middle School will be relocated effective Thursday due to ongoing environmental issues at the building, According to Robert Banzer, the superintendent of the Northport-East Northport Union Free School District.
    Students at Northport Middle School will be relocated effective Thursday due to ongoing environmental issues at the building, According to Robert Banzer, the superintendent of the Northport-East Northport Union Free School District.
  • Rainy conditions move in behind winter storm

    Rainy conditions move in behind winter storm

    Saturday, January 18 2020 10:26 PM EST2020-01-19 03:26:58 GMT
    Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.
    Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.
    Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.
    Rain has moved in behind Saturday’s snowfall that dropped several inches during the afternoon.
  • President Trump team, House managers trade sharp views on impeachment

    President Trump team, House managers trade sharp views on impeachment

    Saturday, January 18 2020 7:40 PM EST2020-01-19 00:40:44 GMT
    President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion. President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion.
    President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion.President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion.
    President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion.
    President Donald Trump's legal team issued a fiery response ahead of opening arguments in his impeachment trial Saturday while House Democrats laid out their case in forceful fashion.
  • SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>

  • Your January 2020 Storm Photos

    Your January 2020 Storm Photos

    Have a great or fun photo during snowstorms in January 2020? We want to see them!
    Have a great or fun photo during snowstorms in January 2020? We want to see them!
  • Dog Day Fridays for Jan. 17

    Dog Day Fridays for Jan. 17

    Friday, January 17 2020 10:01 AM EST2020-01-17 15:01:18 GMT
    Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.
    Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.Lady is a Labrador/Rottweiler mix. She is super affectionate and her favorite pasttime is dancing! She loves belly rubs and snuggling with all people.
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Ruff House Rescue. They brought three puppies!
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Ruff House Rescue. They brought three puppies!
  • It's National Dress Up Your Pet Day - Submit your photos

    It's National Dress Up Your Pet Day - Submit your photos

    Tuesday, January 14 2020 5:36 AM EST2020-01-14 10:36:44 GMT
    Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?
    Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?Happy National Dress Up Your Pet Day! Do you dress up your pet?
    According to the National Retail Federation, Americans were expected to spend $490 million on costumes for their pets this past Halloween. But there's another special day to celebrate your furry friend!
    According to the National Retail Federation, Americans were expected to spend $490 million on costumes for their pets this past Halloween. But there's another special day to celebrate your furry friend!
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."