Man found guilty of killing Farmingdale woman in 2002 has conviction overturned

Posted: Updated:

A man who has served over 17 years in prison after being found guilty of killing a Farmingdale woman in 2002 has had his conviction overturned by a federal court.

The justices threw out the murder conviction, saying Paul Scrimo's constitutional rights were violated during his trial in May 2002.

Scrimo has challenged his conviction for years. In his latest challenge, Scrimo's attorney Randall Unger argued that three key defense witnesses were not allowed to testify at trial.

In the decision, the justices agreed writing, "We conclude that the trial court's exclusion of three defense witnesses violated Scrimo's constitutional right to present a complete defense. Accordingly, we reverse and remand the judgment of the district court."

The judges also noted DNA under the victim's fingernails belonged to another man.

Scrimo was convicted in the killing of floral designer Ruth Williams, who was strangled in her Farmingdale apartment in April 2000.

Unger says the conviction was based on testimony of a sole witness, who claimed Scrimo killed Williams because she had called his wife "fat and ugly."

Williams' brother tells News 12 the appeals court judges were wrong to overturn Scrimo's conviction, calling it a bitter disappointment.

Scrimo won't be released from prison until prosecutors decide whether to seek a retrial. A spokesperson for Nassau Districy Attorney Madeline Singas says her office is reviewing the decision but has not decided whether to retry the case.

Scrimo was serving 25 years to life in prison when the appeals court decided to toss out the conviction.

 

  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • Officials break ground on new Islanders arena at Belmont Park

    Officials break ground on new Islanders arena at Belmont Park

    Monday, September 23 2019 5:12 PM EDT2019-09-23 21:12:45 GMT
    An official groundbreaking ceremony took place Monday for the new Islanders arena at Belmont Park.
    An official groundbreaking ceremony took place Monday for the new Islanders arena at Belmont Park.
  • School Spirit Showdown: Vote on the Top 12 schools

    School Spirit Showdown: Vote on the Top 12 schools

    It's a battle for bragging rights! News 12 is looking for the schools with the most school spirit! Is it yours?

    It's a battle for bragging rights! News 12 is looking for the schools with the most school spirit! Is it yours?

  • Hate at Home: A Team 12 Investigates Special Report

    Hate at Home: A Team 12 Investigates Special Report

    Monday, September 23 2019 5:19 PM EDT2019-09-23 21:19:11 GMT
    In Hate at Home, a special network-wide News 12 investigation, our team examines hate crime data from across the tri-state area and speaks to those whose lives have been impacted by acts of hate.
    In Hate at Home, a special network-wide News 12 investigation, our team examines hate crime data from across the tri-state area and speaks to those whose lives have been impacted by acts of hate.
  • SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>

  • 71st annual Emmy Awards

    71st annual Emmy Awards

    Sights and scenes from the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards, held Sunday, Sept. 22, 2019, at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles.
    Sights and scenes from the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards, held Sunday, Sept. 22, 2019, at the Microsoft Theater in Los Angeles.
  • Scenes from 'Alienstock' at Area 51 in Nevada

    Scenes from 'Alienstock' at Area 51 in Nevada

    While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.
    While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.
    While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.
    While costumed space aliens were a common and sometimes hilarious sight in events that began Thursday, no one has reported seeing actual extraterrestrials or UFOs.
  • Fans sample dishes from ballparks across the US at MLB FoodFest

    Fans sample dishes from ballparks across the US at MLB FoodFest

    Fans taste tested some of the most popular dishes from all 30 Major League ballparks across the country in Manhattan this past weekend.
    Fans taste tested some of the most popular dishes from all 30 Major League ballparks across the country in Manhattan this past weekend.
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."