Columbus Day-Indigenous Peoples Day controversy erupts again in Southampton
Posted: Updated:Tempers flared as the controversy over celebrating Columbus Day boiled over once again in the Southampton School District, with a board meeting ending in yet another change to the holiday's name.
The debate pitted members of the Shinnecock Indian Nation against pro-Columbus advocates seeking to reverse a district decision to rename the holiday on its calendar.
"To sit there and celebrate a man...that has raped, murdered and stole is a slap in the face," says Nichol Dennis-Banks, a Shinnecock Tribe member.
As News 12 reported three years ago, the calendar controversy started when some Native American students in the district pushed to change Columbus Day to Indigenous Peoples Day. They said the goal was to celebrate everyone involved in America's founding.
MORE: Columbus Day or Indigenous Peoples Day? LIers weigh in | Southampton schools mull renaming Columbus Day
Some Italian-Americans in the district wanted to keep Columbus Day as a day to honor their achievements.
"All to malign this man as a brutal sadistic invader, it's totally, abjectly untrue," says Lou Gallo, of Sons of Italy.
Last year, the board voted in favor of renaming the holiday. But Tuesday night pro-Columbus advocates, including Gallo, pleaded with the board to put Columbus Day back on the calendar.
"If you want to do tolerance and diversity, you do it by addition, not by subtraction," says Gallo.
In the end, the board voted 4-3 to change the name yet again to "Indigenous Peoples Day/Italian Heritage Day."
Some residents say the controversy has gotten out of hand, while others think the change is a good compromise.
"I think it's cool that they're incorporating a lot more people into it, so I feel like that's good for everyone," says Southampton High School sophomore Isabelle Kadash.
NewsMore>>
Fire razes home in Old Westbury; 150 firefighters respond to blaze
Fire razes home in Old Westbury; 150 firefighters respond to blaze
Firefighters battled a blaze at a home in Old Westbury Saturday morning.Firefighters battled a blaze at a home in Old Westbury Saturday morning.Bethpage FD: SUV smashes into Subway restaurant, injuring 8-year-old girl
Bethpage FD: SUV smashes into Subway restaurant, injuring 8-year-old girl
Pictures from the incident show the Honda almost completely inside the Boundary Plaza strip mall shop, and a parking pylon knocked on its side.
Pictures from the incident show the Honda almost completely inside the Boundary Plaza strip mall shop, and a parking pylon knocked on its side.
A Honda CR-V smashed into a Subway restaurant Saturday, according to the Bethpage Fire Department.A Honda CR-V smashed into a Subway restaurant Saturday, according to the Bethpage Fire Department.Sewanhaka High School security guard accused of sexually assaulting 15-year-old girl
Sewanhaka High School security guard accused of sexually assaulting 15-year-old girl
Police say a high school security guard is accused of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl.Police say a high school security guard is accused of sexually assaulting a 15-year-old girl.Police: Man, woman tied up in Freeport during armed home invasion
Police: Man, woman tied up in Freeport during armed home invasion
Two people were tied up and held at gunpoint during an attempted robbery Friday night at a Freeport home, police say.
Two people were tied up and held at gunpoint during an attempted robbery Friday night at a Freeport home, police say.
Two people were tied up and held at gunpoint during an attempted robbery Friday night at a Freeport home, police say.Two people were tied up and held at gunpoint during an attempted robbery Friday night at a Freeport home, police say.NYPD officials: Razor found in deli sandwich that injured officer was an accident
NYPD officials: Razor found in deli sandwich that injured officer was an accident
On Saturday, NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea tweeted that after a thorough investigation, "It has been determined that the razor incident was indeed an accident."
On Saturday, NYPD Commissioner Dermot Shea tweeted that after a thorough investigation, "It has been determined that the razor incident was indeed an accident."
The NYPD officer injured after biting into a sandwich that contained a razor blade was the result of an accident, NYPD officials say.The NYPD officer injured after biting into a sandwich that contained a razor blade was the result of an accident, NYPD officials say.
SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>
Dog Day Fridays for Dec. 6
Dog Day Fridays for Dec. 6
Manny is a 5-month-old male, Lab/Spaniel mix from Texas. He's an extremely playful, energetic and bouncy pup. He would thrive in a high energy home!
Manny is a 5-month-old male, Lab/Spaniel mix from Texas. He's an extremely playful, energetic and bouncy pup. He would thrive in a high energy home!
This week's dogs are up for adoption at Kent Animal Shelter. The shelter is located at 2259 River Road Calverton, NY 11933. Their phone number is 631-727-5731.This week's dogs are up for adoption at Kent Animal Shelter. The shelter is located at 2259 River Road Calverton, NY 11933. Their phone number is 631-727-5731.Chinese lantern festival lights up the sky above Citi Field for the holiday season
Chinese lantern festival lights up the sky above Citi Field for the holiday season
A new lantern festival has taken over Citi Field, lighting up the sky starting Friday.A new lantern festival has taken over Citi Field, lighting up the sky starting Friday.Your Long Island 2019 Holiday Photos
Your Long Island 2019 Holiday Photos
From sparking holiday lights to fun Santa photos, News 12 wants to see your holiday photos!From sparking holiday lights to fun Santa photos, News 12 wants to see your holiday photos!2019 Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Lighting
2019 Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Lighting
The 87th annual Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree lighting ceremony was held Wednesday, Dec. 4, 2019 in New York.The 87th annual Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree lighting ceremony was held Wednesday, Dec. 4, 2019 in New York.Your December 2019 Storm Photos
Your December 2019 Storm Photos
Do you have photos of the winter storm from the December 2019 storm? We want to see!Do you have photos of the winter storm from the December 2019 storm? We want to see!