Attorneys target Singh’s credibility in closing statements

Posted: Updated:
CENTRAL ISLIP -

In his summation Wednesday, the attorney for former Nassau County Executive Ed Mangano called the prosecution’s star witness a liar who loved to give lavish gifts to his friends.

Kevin Keating said that restaurateur Harendra Singh never received anything of value in return from Ed Mangano, and said that his client’s life is on the line.

MORE: Attorneys give closing statements in Mangano-Venditto trial

In respect to a lucrative catering contract Singh received from the Nassau Office of Emergency Management after Superstorm Sandy, Keating said that decision came from the state over health concerns, not Mangano.

"If there wasn't a superstorm, Harendra Singh would have received nothing from Nassau County. Nothing," said Keating.

The prosecution argued for nine weeks that Singh used bribes and kickbacks to secure favors from Ed Mangano and Oyster Bay Town Supervisor John Venditto – both of whom are facing federal corruption charges.

One of those alleged favors was a $100,000 a year no-show or low-show job for Ed Mangano’s wife Linda. 

Her attorney John Carman surmised that Singh was a liar in his closing remarks. Carman said the case against Linda Mangano is whether or not she lied to FBI agents. He argued that since the prosecution never provided transcripts or audio recordings of her comments, the jury cannot convict her.

In the afternoon, it was Venditto’s attorney Marc Angifilo's turn. He described his client as a humble man who has lived in the same home for years, worked in the same job for nearly two decades and doesn't even own a passport. He described Singh as a "sociopath."

He argued that while Singh fostered a "good guy" image with Venditto, he was quietly working with Oyster Bay Deputy Attorney Fred Mei to advance his interests at the town's expense.

"They found each other because they are both criminals. Criminals find each other, and they did,” said Agnifilo.

Agnifilo compared Singh and Mei, who each have pleaded guilty to a litany of crimes and have cooperation agreements with the government, to “Bonny and Clyde.”

He also accused the feds of "dumping on the town of Oyster Bay."

That remark drew eye rolls from some, and prompted prosecutor Lara Treinis Gatz to look back toward the gallery and smirk.

Prosecutor Catherine Mirable will offer a rebuttal to the defense summations Thursday.

  • SlideshowsGalleriesMore>>

  • Dog Day Fridays for May 17

    Dog Day Fridays for May 17

    Friday, May 17 2019 11:13 AM EDT2019-05-17 15:13:26 GMT
    Scruff is a cute little girl looking for love! This shaggy dog came from Puerto Rico and is ready for a whole new life. She would do well in a home with other dogs, children of any age, and can even live amongst cats.Scruff is a cute little girl looking for love! This shaggy dog came from Puerto Rico and is ready for a whole new life. She would do well in a home with other dogs, children of any age, and can even live amongst cats.
    Scruff is a cute little girl looking for love! This shaggy dog came from Puerto Rico and is ready for a whole new life. She would do well in a home with other dogs, children of any age, and can even live amongst cats.Scruff is a cute little girl looking for love! This shaggy dog came from Puerto Rico and is ready for a whole new life. She would do well in a home with other dogs, children of any age, and can even live amongst cats.
    This week's pets are up for adoption at Southampton Animal Shelter. The shelter is located at 102 Old Riverhead Road West in Hampton Bays. Their phone number is 631-728-7387.
    This week's pets are up for adoption at Southampton Animal Shelter. The shelter is located at 102 Old Riverhead Road West in Hampton Bays. Their phone number is 631-728-7387.
  • 2019 PGA Championship Photos

    2019 PGA Championship Photos

    Are you attending the PGA Championship?  News 12 wants to see your photos!
    Are you attending the PGA Championship?  News 12 wants to see your photos!
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."