Environmental groups file intent to sue fishing company
Posted: Updated:The Earth Justice environmental law firm is churning up the tide against a fishing company accused of "strip mining" the waters of Oyster Bay, according to a notice of intent to sue.
Kevin McCallister of Defend H20 -- another group involved in the legal process -- says the Frank M. Flower & Sons shellfish farming operation uses hydraulic dredges and vacuum suction to collect its catch.
"The constant impact to the bottom is extremely destructive," McCallister says.
That's because Flower & Sons' boats allegedly use high-power jets to churn up the bay's floor as part of the fishing operation.
"At the crux of the issue is there isn't proper permitting to allow the operation to continue," McCallister says. "That's at the center of the intent to sue. They do not have the permits. If the agencies would actually scrutinize the operation, then it would be very difficult to issue the permits under the Clean Water Act."
Traditional clammers like Bill Painter and the members of the North Oyster Bay Baymen's Association have been at odds with Flower & Sons for years over its hydraulic harvesters.
"It's mind-blowing they can conduct an operation like this in a national wildlife refuge," Painter says.
Earth Justice says even the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation has recognized hydraulic dredging as "especially destructive."
For its part, Flower & Sons issued a statement dismissing the intent to sue, implying that Earth Justice was just siding with its competitors.
"Frank M. Flower operates in compliance with all required federal, state and local laws," the statement concluded.
As far as the Town of Oyster Bay is concerned, officials there say the dredging issue is out of their hands -- and their clam rakes -- as a matter of state and federal law.
MORE: Read the notice of intent to sue below:
EnvironmentMore>>
Nassau officials visit Massachusetts anti-flood barrier
Nassau officials visit Massachusetts anti-flood barrier
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
State lawmakers eye fertilizer ban to save LI water
State lawmakers eye fertilizer ban to save LI water
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
Navy report on radium in water irks Bethpage residents
Navy report on radium in water irks Bethpage residents
Many Bethpage residents are dismissing a new report put out by the Navy about radium found in Bethpage water supplies.
Many Bethpage residents are dismissing a new report put out by the Navy about radium found in Bethpage water supplies.
Many Bethpage residents are dismissing a new report put out by the Navy about radium found in Bethpage water supplies.
Gov. Cuomo unveils plan to enhance reefs off Long Island
Gov. Cuomo unveils plan to enhance reefs off Long Island
The plan will give fishermen more places to catch fish and help increase the amount they get.
The plan will give fishermen more places to catch fish and help increase the amount they get.
Dangerous chemical compound found in E. Quogue sample well
Dangerous chemical compound found in E. Quogue sample well
An East End community's drinking water may be contaminated with a dangerous chemical compound.
An East End community's drinking water may be contaminated with a dangerous chemical compound.
PSEG to fix flap over osprey nest removal
PSEG to fix flap over osprey nest removal
A squawk over PSEG Long Island's removal of an osprey nest to make power lines repairs has hatched a plan to relocate the birds' home.
A squawk over PSEG Long Island's removal of an osprey nest to make power lines repairs has hatched a plan to relocate the birds' home.
A squawk over PSEG Long Island's removal of an osprey nest to make power lines repairs has hatched a plan to relocate the birds' home.
Beach restoration begins in Montauk
Beach restoration begins in Montauk
Crews began replenishing sand on Montauk's storm-battered downtown beach Monday, a monthlong project to restore the beachfront before the summer season.
Crews began replenishing sand on Montauk's storm-battered downtown beach Monday, a monthlong project to restore the beachfront before the summer season.
Crews began replenishing sand on Montauk's storm-battered downtown beach Monday, a monthlong project to restore the beachfront before the summer season.
Environmental groups file intent to sue fishing company
Environmental groups file intent to sue fishing company
The Earth Justice environmental group is churning up the tide against a fishing company accused of "strip mining" the waters of Oyster Bay, according to a notice of intent to sue.
The Earth Justice environmental group is churning up the tide against a fishing company accused of "strip mining" the waters of Oyster Bay, according to a notice of intent to sue.
The Earth Justice environmental group is churning up the tide against a fishing company accused of "strip mining" the waters of Oyster Bay, according to a notice of intent to sue.
Plans to expand Bayport senior apartment complex faces opposition
Plans to expand Bayport senior apartment complex faces opposition
Developers want to build more than 150 new senior apartments in Bayport, but opponents say the new units would be built on land that was never meant to be developed. T
Developers want to build more than 150 new senior apartments in Bayport, but opponents say the new units would be built on land that was never meant to be developed. T
Army Corps project in Long Beach an 'inconvenience' for residents
Army Corps project in Long Beach an 'inconvenience' for residents
As the Army Corps of Engineers begins its construction project to strengthen the Long Beach shore, some residents are calling it an inconvenience.
As the Army Corps of Engineers begins its construction project to strengthen the Long Beach shore, some residents are calling it an inconvenience.
Long Island Top StoriesMore>>
Director outlines plan to improve aging Northport VA
Director outlines plan to improve aging Northport VA
The director of the problem-plagued Northport VA Medical Center on Monday outlined a multiyear, multimillion-dollar plan to improve the aging facility.
The director of the problem-plagued Northport VA Medical Center on Monday outlined a multiyear, multimillion-dollar plan to improve the aging facility.
The director of the problem-plagued Northport VA Medical Center on Monday outlined a multiyear, multimillion-dollar plan to improve the aging facility.
The director of the problem-plagued Northport VA Medical Center on Monday outlined a multiyear, multimillion-dollar plan to improve the aging facility.
Wild bus ride on senior trip to DC startles students
Wild bus ride on senior trip to DC startles students
A senior trip to the nation's capital over the weekend included a wild bus ride for some students from Sachem High School North.
A senior trip to the nation's capital over the weekend included a wild bus ride for some Long Island high school students.
A senior trip to the nation's capital over the weekend included a wild bus ride for some Long Island high school students.
Legendary Met Ed Kranepool needs kidney transplant
Legendary Met Ed Kranepool needs kidney transplant
Legendary New York Mets first baseman Ed Kranepool has two failing kidneys and needs a transplant, he says.
Legendary New York Mets first baseman Ed Kranepool has two failing kidneys and needs a transplant, he says.
Legendary New York Mets first baseman Ed Kranepool has two failing kidneys and needs a transplant, he says.
Finance exec: Singh facilitated loans backed by Oyster Bay Town
Finance exec: Singh facilitated loans backed by Oyster Bay Town
A finance executive linked a disgraced restaurateur to about $20 million in loans backed by the Town of Oyster Bay Monday during testimony in the federal corruption trial against Ed Mangano and John Venditto.
A finance executive linked a disgraced restaurateur to about $20 million in loans backed by the Town of Oyster Bay Monday during testimony in the federal corruption trial against Ed Mangano and John Venditto.
Nassau officials visit Massachusetts anti-flood barrier
Nassau officials visit Massachusetts anti-flood barrier
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
Freeport Mayor Robert Kennedy led a contingent of Nassau County lawmakers to Massachusetts Monday for a firsthand look at some flood prevention measures.
Waffle House slaying suspect arrested after massive manhunt
Waffle House slaying suspect arrested after massive manhunt
The suspect in a quadruple homicide at a Nashville Waffle House was taken into custody Monday, police said.
The suspect in a quadruple homicide at a Nashville Waffle House was taken into custody Monday, police said.
9 dead, 16 hurt when van hits pedestrians in Toronto
9 dead, 16 hurt when van hits pedestrians in Toronto
Toronto police say nine people are dead and 16 are injured after a van struck pedestrians in the city Monday.
Toronto police say nine people are dead and 16 are injured after a van struck pedestrians in the city Monday.
Sisters urge those exposed to Chernobyl radiation to get cancer checks
Sisters urge those exposed to Chernobyl radiation to get cancer checks
Two Long Island sisters, who were exposed to radiation at Chernobyl, are urging others exposed to get checked for various types of cancer.
Two Long Island sisters, who were exposed to radiation at Chernobyl, are urging others exposed to get checked for various types of cancer.
State lawmakers eye fertilizer ban to save LI water
State lawmakers eye fertilizer ban to save LI water
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
To help protect waters around Long Island, some state lawmakers are pushing for limits on some common fertilizers.
Business Briefs: Netflix, Amazon, Kanye West
Business Briefs: Netflix, Amazon, Kanye West
Netflix is raising its debt to finance new content.
Netflix is raising its debt to finance new content.