News 12 examines ‘acting’ commissioners on LI

Posted: Updated:
MINEOLA -

Thomas Krumpter has been acting Nassau police commissioner for years but was in no hurry to get his title changed – and News 12 is taking a look at why.

Krumpter has served in his role for more than three years. By remaining “acting” commissioner, he has been able to earn thousands of dollars more than the county allows for an official hiring. Krumpter’s also not the only one in this type of situation – James Davis has been acting commissioner of Nassau’s Assessment Department for six years.

Municipal law expert Paul Sabatino says the use of acting commissioners to serve for an indefinite period of time is part of a troubling, if not illegal, trend. He argues that in nearly every instance, state law does not allow for the appointment of "acting commissioners." That's why departments have deputies or vice presidents.  As a result, Sabatino says municipalities are subject to legal challenges in response to any decision or ruling made by an “acting commissioner."

“It’s a powerful legal argument, which is what power, what authority did you have, since the title doesn't exist?” says Sabatino.

Property valuation attorney Laureen Harris recently filed suit against Nassau County on behalf of several small business owners who are contesting new penalties imposed by acting Assessment Commissioner Davis.  One of her arguments is that Davis continues to be “acting” assessor.

And what about the issue of transparency and the need for public vetting? Some lawmakers say by appointing acting commissioners, administrations are able to circumvent that process.

“It’s not a transparent government when you are not screening people,” says Legislator Ellen Birnbaum.

Birnbaum points out that while commissioner candidates are subject to legislative approval, acting commissioners operate without that same level of scrutiny. That's why she put forth a bill earlier this year that would limit acting commissioners to six months in office.

“I think we really ought to have somebody who is qualified, is screened, and meets legislative approval,” says Birnbaum.

Krumpter and Nassau County Executive Mangano declined News 12 Long Island’s interview requests. News 12 Long Island also reached out to Presiding Officer Norma Gonsalves, who has declined to bring Legislator Birnbaum's bill up for a vote, but has not heard back.

  • PoliticsMore>>

  • Power & Politics: State Sen. John Brooks

    Power & Politics: State Sen. John Brooks

    Thursday, May 23 2019 10:19 PM EDT2019-05-24 02:19:31 GMT
    State Sen. John Brooks stopped by the News 12 studio to answer viewer questions and cover topics such as veterans' issues, school funding, tax relief and more.
    State Sen. John Brooks stopped by the News 12 studio to answer viewer questions and cover topics such as veterans' issues, school funding, tax relief and more.
  • Trump meeting with Dems goes bust in a flash

    Trump meeting with Dems goes bust in a flash

    Wednesday, May 22 2019 8:52 PM EDT2019-05-23 00:52:15 GMT
    Prospects for passing a large infrastructure bill evaporated Wednesday as Trump announced that he won't work with Democratic lawmakers on policy while they continue to investigate him.
    Prospects for passing a large infrastructure bill evaporated Wednesday as Trump announced that he won't work with Democratic lawmakers on policy while they continue to investigate him.
  • Nassau ban on Styrofoam containers going into effect next year

    Nassau ban on Styrofoam containers going into effect next year

    Monday, May 20 2019 6:06 PM EDT2019-05-20 22:06:31 GMT
    The Nassau County Legislature on Monday unanimously passed a ban on the use of polystyrene, or Styrofoam, containers.
    The Nassau County Legislature on Monday unanimously passed a ban on the use of polystyrene, or Styrofoam, containers.
  • Top StoriesMore>>

  • SPCA: 76 cats rescued from uninhabitable Mastic Beach home; man charged

    SPCA: 76 cats rescued from uninhabitable Mastic Beach home; man charged

    Thursday, May 23 2019 10:25 PM EDT2019-05-24 02:25:53 GMT
    The Suffolk County SPCA says 76 cats, including five kittens, were rescued from deplorable conditions inside a Mastic Beach home.
    The Suffolk County SPCA says 76 cats, including five kittens, were rescued from deplorable conditions inside a Mastic Beach home.
  • Guide: 2019 Memorial Day Parades on LI

    Guide: 2019 Memorial Day Parades on LI

    Memorial Day parades are planned across Long Island. Here is a list of some parades. 

    Memorial Day parades are planned across Long Island. Here is a list of some parades. 

  • Dog Day Fridays for May 24

    Dog Day Fridays for May 24

    Friday, May 24 2019 4:55 AM EDT2019-05-24 08:55:03 GMT
    Devin is a 2-year-old, male, Lab/Pit Bull mix rescued from a high-kill shelter. He was heartworm positive and has since received his treatments and ready to find his forever home.Devin is a 2-year-old, male, Lab/Pit Bull mix rescued from a high-kill shelter. He was heartworm positive and has since received his treatments and ready to find his forever home.
    Devin is a 2-year-old, male, Lab/Pit Bull mix rescued from a high-kill shelter. He was heartworm positive and has since received his treatments and ready to find his forever home.Devin is a 2-year-old, male, Lab/Pit Bull mix rescued from a high-kill shelter. He was heartworm positive and has since received his treatments and ready to find his forever home.
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Almost Home Animal Rescue & Adoption. The shelter is located at 646 Medford Ave. in Patchogue. Their phone number is (631) 627-3665.
    This week's dogs are up for adoption at Almost Home Animal Rescue & Adoption. The shelter is located at 646 Medford Ave. in Patchogue. Their phone number is (631) 627-3665.
sorry to interrupt
your first 20 are free
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please enjoy 20 complimentary views of articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.
you have reached your 20 view limit
Access to News 12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Spectrum Networks® and Service ElectricSM customers.
Please login or create an account to continue enjoying News12.
Our sign-up page is undergoing maintenance and is not currently available. However, you will be given direct access to news12.com while we complete our upgrade.
When we are back up and running you will be prompted at that time to complete your sign in. Until then, enjoy the local news, weather, traffic and more that's "as local as local news gets."