Trial begins for Manorville man accused of murdering 2 women

<p>Prosecutor Robert Biancavilla told the jury that 50-year-old John Bittrolff Jr. viciously murdered two prostitutes, who were both found nude and strangled with their skulls crushed.&nbsp;</p>

News 12 Staff

May 3, 2017, 11:08 PM

Updated 2,554 days ago

Share:

Trial begins for Manorville man accused of murdering 2 women
Attorneys made their opening statements Wednesday in the trial of a Manorville man accused of murdering two women in the early 1990s. 
Prosecutor Robert Biancavilla told the jury that 50-year-old John Bittrolff Jr. viciously murdered two prostitutes, who were both found nude and strangled with their skulls crushed. 
Rita Tangredi was found in November 1993 in East Patchogue, and Colleen McNamee was found in January 1994 in Shirley. Both discoveries were made in wooded areas. 
The prosecutor explained to the jury how DNA evidence from Bittrolff's brother, who had been arrested in 2013 in an unrelated case, led detectives to him. His brother's DNA had been entered into a state DNA database and showed a family connection to the DNA recovered from both murder scenes. 
"We have very sound proof that he is the killer," said Biancavilla. 
During his opening arguments, defense attorney William Keahon told the jury that the presence of his client's DNA does not mean that he is their killer.
John Bittrollf's trial will continue Thursday and is expected to last several weeks.
 


More from News 12
3:42
Students at Stony Brook University take part in pro-Palestinian protest

Students at Stony Brook University take part in pro-Palestinian protest

2:00
Sun and warm temps through end of workweek, rain possible this weekend

Sun and warm temps through end of workweek, rain possible this weekend

0:21
School officials: Cyberattack causes internet, phone outage at Mineola Public Schools

School officials: Cyberattack causes internet, phone outage at Mineola Public Schools

2:05
'He didn't care about the consequences.’ Man pleads guilty to East Massapequa crash that killed 4

'He didn't care about the consequences.’ Man pleads guilty to East Massapequa crash that killed 4

1:51
Students like food, not prices, from food trucks brought in by NCC following dining services closure

Students like food, not prices, from food trucks brought in by NCC following dining services closure

0:32
Prosecutors: Shirley woman sold misbranded, adulterated weight loss drugs on TikTok

Prosecutors: Shirley woman sold misbranded, adulterated weight loss drugs on TikTok

0:26
Mets partner with Smithtown nonprofit to raise future service dog for veteran or first responder

Mets partner with Smithtown nonprofit to raise future service dog for veteran or first responder

0:24
Man, woman wanted for stealing wallet in Huntington Station

Man, woman wanted for stealing wallet in Huntington Station

0:27
MTA approves plan to discount monthly LIRR tickets for NYC, excludes Long Island

MTA approves plan to discount monthly LIRR tickets for NYC, excludes Long Island

1:32
Public hearing held on Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital's filing for additional parking

Public hearing held on Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital's filing for additional parking

1:46
What's Cooking: Steak Taco

What's Cooking: Steak Taco

2:57
Garden Guide: Food you can grow anywhere

Garden Guide: Food you can grow anywhere

Guide: Mental health resources available in the tri-state

Guide: Mental health resources available in the tri-state

1:59
EXCLUSIVE: Father of teen boy killed in Jericho 1 year ago urges governor to sign Grieving Families Act

EXCLUSIVE: Father of teen boy killed in Jericho 1 year ago urges governor to sign Grieving Families Act

1:55
Public hearing held over proposal to bring a walkable downtown to Melville

Public hearing held over proposal to bring a walkable downtown to Melville

2:01
US Preventative Services Task Force updates guidance for women to start getting mammograms at age 40

US Preventative Services Task Force updates guidance for women to start getting mammograms at age 40

0:33
Family: Floral Park teen struck by dirt bike in Albany in critical condition

Family: Floral Park teen struck by dirt bike in Albany in critical condition

0:53
USDA report: Long Island Game Farm giraffe was malnourished before death

USDA report: Long Island Game Farm giraffe was malnourished before death

1:53
Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

Shop Mother’s Day Gifts – Exclusive Offers Up to 75% OFF!

2:27
Town of Hempstead IDA holds hearing on Hillcrest of Floral Park apartments

Town of Hempstead IDA holds hearing on Hillcrest of Floral Park apartments