Controversy remains after Suffolk's top cop resigns

Suffolk's top uniformed officer stepped down Tuesday citing personal and family reasons, but the controversy surrounding his resignation has not yet gone away. James Burke's departure comes at the

News 12 Staff

Oct 29, 2015, 2:08 AM

Updated 3,094 days ago

Share:

Controversy remains after Suffolk's top cop resigns
Suffolk's top uniformed officer stepped down Tuesday citing personal and family reasons, but the controversy surrounding his resignation has not yet gone away.
James Burke's departure comes at the same time as what appears to be a renewed federal investigation into alleged police misconduct. News 12 Long Island has confirmed that several Suffolk police officers have been issued subpoenas within the past few weeks, some as recently as today, to appear before a federal grand jury.
As News 12 has reported, federal authorities are looking into allegations made by Christopher Loeb, of Smithtown, who claims Burke beat him up after he was arrested for stealing a duffel bag out of Burke's SUV.
No charges have been filed against Burke. Still, Loeb's attorney Bruce Barket says his client does feel slightly vindicated that he is resigning.
"I'm not surprised that the chief is leaving his position. Frankly I was surprised he was allowed to stay in it as long as he was," says Barket.
Republican Legislator Robert Trotta (R - Fort Salonga), a former Suffolk police detective, questions how and why Burke was promoted so high.
"This guy had a high school education, a jaded background and rumors rampant around the department that he was in trouble all the time," Trotta tells News 12.
Supporters say Burke dedicated his career to improving the department. Suffolk PBA president Noel DiGerolamo called his departure "a tremendous loss to the department."
A statement from Executive Steve Bellone's spokesperson says the executive "is focused on making tough decisions based on what is in the best interest of Suffolk County residents and the men and women of the Suffolk County Police Department. Over the last four years crime has dropped 20 percent in Suffolk County and we are focusing our efforts on continuing that downward trend."
 


More from News 12
1:49
Police: Car drives into Plainview dance studio; 3 suffer minor injuries

Police: Car drives into Plainview dance studio; 3 suffer minor injuries

2:26
Brightening skies and warmer temperatures heading into the weekend

Brightening skies and warmer temperatures heading into the weekend

0:23
Police: Hempstead man stole parking meters near Jericho Turnpike and Roslyn Road

Police: Hempstead man stole parking meters near Jericho Turnpike and Roslyn Road

1:55
8-year-old from Valley Stream becomes first in NY to undergo gene therapy for rare disease

8-year-old from Valley Stream becomes first in NY to undergo gene therapy for rare disease

2:27
2016 whistleblower tip warned of barrels buried at old Grumman property in Bethpage

2016 whistleblower tip warned of barrels buried at old Grumman property in Bethpage

0:25
Long Islander wins $1,000 a day for life from lotto ticket

Long Islander wins $1,000 a day for life from lotto ticket

1:34
Police: Drunk driver hits patrol car at scene of DWI crash; Suffolk officer hurt

Police: Drunk driver hits patrol car at scene of DWI crash; Suffolk officer hurt

2:00
Police: Man’s wallet blocks bullet during Coram shooting; suspect wanted

Police: Man’s wallet blocks bullet during Coram shooting; suspect wanted

0:44
NuHealth holds breast cancer screenings at Plainview-Old Bethpage Library

NuHealth holds breast cancer screenings at Plainview-Old Bethpage Library

0:49
Suffolk Sheriff’s Office holds 1st wellness conference at Suffolk Community College

Suffolk Sheriff’s Office holds 1st wellness conference at Suffolk Community College

0:13
Police probe shooting incident at Patchogue home

Police probe shooting incident at Patchogue home

0:23
West Islip man sentenced to 8 1/3 to 25 years for stealing millions from Williston Park school

West Islip man sentenced to 8 1/3 to 25 years for stealing millions from Williston Park school

0:25
Police: Man threw cellphone, injured officer responding to disturbance on road in Valley Stream

Police: Man threw cellphone, injured officer responding to disturbance on road in Valley Stream

1:09
The East End: Hamptons Handpoured

The East End: Hamptons Handpoured

1:52
Find fun, interactive activities for family and friends at Main Street Board Game Café in Huntington

Find fun, interactive activities for family and friends at Main Street Board Game Café in Huntington

0:37
North Babylon HS gives away dresses, suits ahead of prom season

North Babylon HS gives away dresses, suits ahead of prom season

0:22
Central Islip man sentenced to 22 years in prison for raping daughter

Central Islip man sentenced to 22 years in prison for raping daughter

1:45
Long Island pizzerias come together to raise funds for family of slain detective

Long Island pizzerias come together to raise funds for family of slain detective

0:30
Hempstead man pleads guilty, gets 8 years for drug trafficking

Hempstead man pleads guilty, gets 8 years for drug trafficking

0:19
Nassau Legislature approves 2 new outdoor fields for Mitchel Athletic Complex

Nassau Legislature approves 2 new outdoor fields for Mitchel Athletic Complex