Evicted Waterview Club owner Paul Burnup, who allegedly owes thousands for canceled weddings, opens new restaurant

A man whose catering hall abruptly closed is now opening a restaurant in Freeport, infuriating brides and grooms who were left in the lurch. The

The Waterview Club leased its property from the American Legion, who says owner Paul Burnup was evicted last month after failing to pay a $200,000 bill for back rent, taxes and utilities over three years.

The Waterview Club leased its property from the American Legion, who says owner Paul Burnup was evicted last month after failing to pay a $200,000 bill for back rent, taxes and utilities over three years. (5/28/13)

FREEPORT - A man whose catering hall abruptly closed is now opening a restaurant in Freeport, infuriating brides and grooms who were left in the lurch.

Tammy Pagnillo's dreams turned to nightmares after she learned that her wedding venue, Waterview Club in Bayville, closed abruptly in mid-April. She says the catering hall would not refund her $16,000. More than a dozen other couples say they suffered the same fate.

The Waterview Club leased its property from the American Legion, who says owner Paul Burnup was evicted last month after failing to pay a $200,000 bill for back rent, taxes and utilities over three years.

Now, couples say they're shocked to learn Burnup is opening a brand new restaurant in Freeport.

Burnup and his attorney say money from the Waterview did not go into the new venture.

Meanwhile, the alleged victims say they just want their money back.

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Top 5 Must See

Riverhead Police arrested 4 men for criminal trespassing 1 Police: 4 in Splish Splash BMX video arrested
In 1942, the Georgian Revival house became a 2 LI Hidden Past: Orphan Tree at Brookwood Hall
News 12's Elizabeth Hashagen took a look at 3 Holiday Help: The Nutcracker
One or more burglars have struck eight homes 4 Suffolk police: W. Islip burglaries a pattern
Gary Leifer, 59, told News 12 Long Island 5 Cancer patient claims officer assaulted him at NUMC

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Features

Need help this holiday season? We've got you Holiday Help Series

Need a gift idea? Perhaps you need a fun idea to do with the kids?

Each week a different shelter visits News 12 Dog Day Fridays Series

Each week a different shelter visits News 12 Long Island with pets up for adoption.