Attorney: Security cam proves innocence of E. Rockaway man

The attorney for the man accused of stealing from several CVS stores and then carjacking a woman in East Rockaway last month spoke exclusively with

According to attorney Mark Nadjar, surveillance video from inside the CVS proves that his client, 59-year-old Davis Melis, is innocent.

According to attorney Mark Nadjar, surveillance video from inside the CVS proves that his client, 59-year-old Davis Melis, is innocent. (5/15/15)

EAST ROCKAWAY - The attorney for the man accused of stealing from several CVS stores and then carjacking a woman in East Rockaway last month spoke exclusively with News 12 about his charges.

According to attorney Mark Nadjar, surveillance video from inside the CVS proves that his client, 59-year-old Davis Melis, is innocent.

"The guy on film is a third wider, just in stature," said Melis. "He's not a fat guy, but he's definitely wider. The face is different. The hair is different, and he walks differently."

Nadjar also points to the bald spot on the man in the video. Melis doesn't have a bald spot. Police and witnesses also told News 12 that they struggled with the carjacking suspect and couldn't stop him.

"Melis is not even in good enough health to be able to get away from these people, so I just find it incredible as a matter of common sense and reasonableness," said Nadjar.

As News 12 has reported, the carjacking victim's neighbor says her husband and father-in-law both picked Melis out of a photo lineup last month. Nadjar had previously said that his client was in Suffolk County around the time of the crime and could not have been the suspect.

"Photo lineups are a lot less reliable than the real thing, him standing there," said Nadjar. "Frankly, you don't have to believe me. Just look at the video tape. It's not him."

advertisement | advertise on News 12

Top 5 Must See

A person was killed in a crash involving 1 Police: Person killed in crash with school bus in Ronkonkoma
Police say Jeustin David Maldonado, 17, of Uniondale, 2 Teen charged in connection to Uniondale fatal shooting
Southampton High School is proposing to bump the 3 East End high school proposes later school start
Police gave the 4 Oceanside Jewish center, 27 nationwide receive bomb threats
An upstate company says it wants to use 5 Garbage haul proposal concerns Holtsville residents

advertisement | advertise on News 12

More News

The suspected shoplifter carjacked a 23-year-old woman's vehicle Shoplifter carjacks woman's vehicle in driveway

A man remains on the loose after police say he stole from an Ocean Avenue

David Melis, 59, was arrested Friday and had Attorney: Nassau carjacking suspect is the 'wrong man'

The attorney for the man accused of shoplifting at an East Rockaway CVS and the

Sorry to interrupt...

Your first 5 are free

Access to News12 is free for Optimum, Comcast®, Time Warner® and Service Electric℠ video customers.

Please enjoy 5 complimentary views to articles, photos, and videos during the next 30 days.

LOGIN SUBSCRIBE