Jury starts deliberations in Menendez bribery trial

<p>The jury has started&nbsp;deliberations&nbsp;in the bribery trial of U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez and a wealthy friend.</p>

News 12 Staff

Nov 6, 2017, 11:44 AM

Updated 2,378 days ago

Share:

By DAVID PORTER
Associated Press
NEWARK, N.J. (AP) - After nine weeks of testimony and nearly eight hours of closing arguments spread over two days, a jury began deliberating Monday in the bribery trial of Sen. Bob Menendez of New Jersey and a longtime friend in a case that could have implications for a deeply divided Senate in the event of a conviction.
The panel deliberated for about 90 minutes before leaving for the day and will resume Tuesday morning.
If the Democratic senator is convicted and steps down or is voted out by a two-thirds majority before New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie leaves office Jan. 16, the term-limited Republican governor could appoint a replacement. A Democrat holds a comfortable lead in polls ahead of Tuesday's gubernatorial election. Menendez is up for re-election next year.
Menendez is charged with accepting trips on a private jet, luxury vacations and other gifts from Florida eye doctor Salomon Melgen in exchange for pressuring government officials to resolve Melgen's $8.9 million billing dispute with Medicare, a port screening contract in the Dominican Republic and other issues.
Melgen also contributed more than $600,000 to political organizations that supported Menendez directly or indirectly.
The men's friendship predated the alleged bribery conspiracy by more than a decade, and that relationship "destroys each and every one of the counts" against him, Menendez attorney Abbe Lowell told jurors in his closing argument Monday.
In a rebuttal argument, Justice Department attorney Peter Koski quoted a passage from the jury instructions that said friendship can't be used as a defense against bribery in all cases.
"The issue in this case is not whether Sen. Menendez and Dr. Melgen were friends - the issue in this case is whether they committed a crime together," he said.
Prosecutors characterized Menendez as Melgen's "personal senator" during their closing argument last week, but Lowell told jurors the government presented no evidence of an actual agreement between the two men. He said prosecutors instead "desperately tried to create a quid pro quo by listing dates on one side and dates on the other side, and that vast divide in the middle they cannot fill."
He assailed the government for its use of an FBI agent to introduce evidence such as emails and documents relating to meetings Menendez had and interactions with his staffers, rather than calling the actual people to testify,
Prosecutors want jurors to "assume, fill in the gap, guess and speculate about what happened," Lowell said.
Neither man testified, but their attorneys deny any bribery arrangement and say the gifts were reflective of their longtime friendship. Menendez contends his meetings and interactions with officials from the departments of State, Commerce and Health and Human Services were on policy issues and not to lobby for Melgen.
On Monday, Koski accused the defense of having a strategy that "comes down to distraction and misdirection."
Though Menendez may have had interest in broader policy issues when he met with government officials, Koski said, "he was working under the influence of Melgen's gifts. And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what the law calls bribery."
Menendez served in the U.S. House from 1993 until filling the Senate seat vacated when Democrat Jon Corzine became New Jersey governor in 2006.
The trial is the first major federal bribery trial since a 2016 U.S. Supreme Court decision overturned the conviction of former Republican Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell and narrowed the definition of official bribery. The judge in the Menendez trial used wording directly from the McDonnell opinion in giving his instructions to the jury last week.
___
This story has been corrected to show Christie's last day in office is Jan. 16, not Jan. 18.
Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


More from News 12
Police: 1 dead, another seriously injured in West Islip crash

Police: 1 dead, another seriously injured in West Islip crash

2:17
Rainy morning on Mother’s Day on Long Island, tapers by evening

Rainy morning on Mother’s Day on Long Island, tapers by evening

0:18
Police: Car crashes into Garden City Park T-Mobile store

Police: Car crashes into Garden City Park T-Mobile store

0:55
Athletes with visual impairment play charity 'beep baseball' game in Glen Cove

Athletes with visual impairment play charity 'beep baseball' game in Glen Cove

0:57
Northport Fire Department holds extrication tournament in honor of late firefighter

Northport Fire Department holds extrication tournament in honor of late firefighter

0:22
Nassau police probe shooting incident in Manhasset

Nassau police probe shooting incident in Manhasset

1:23
Light show: Severe solar storm produces spectacular auroras across the tri-state

Light show: Severe solar storm produces spectacular auroras across the tri-state

2:03
Why do Black women have the highest death rate for most cancers? A massive study in underway

Why do Black women have the highest death rate for most cancers? A massive study in underway

0:36
Nassau Supreme Court strikes down Blakeman's ban on transgender athletes competing at county-run facilities

Nassau Supreme Court strikes down Blakeman's ban on transgender athletes competing at county-run facilities

1:50
Vehicle owners say their cars are locked in repair shop since mechanic died at end of 2023

Vehicle owners say their cars are locked in repair shop since mechanic died at end of 2023

2:17
Governor plans overhaul of NY’s cannabis rollout following scathing state review

Governor plans overhaul of NY’s cannabis rollout following scathing state review

1:57
Huntington Station church minister arraigned after allegedly sexually abusing 15-year-old girl

Huntington Station church minister arraigned after allegedly sexually abusing 15-year-old girl

2:11
Stony Brook Medicine celebrates success of mobile stroke unit

Stony Brook Medicine celebrates success of mobile stroke unit

1:57
Freeport tenants say growing garbage is attracting vermin

Freeport tenants say growing garbage is attracting vermin

1:43
32 puppies complete first half of training to become service dogs

32 puppies complete first half of training to become service dogs

0:25
Police: Man arrested for exposing himself to 2 teens in East Meadow

Police: Man arrested for exposing himself to 2 teens in East Meadow

9 Kohl's on Long Island to open Babies'R'Us locations. See list of stores

9 Kohl's on Long Island to open Babies'R'Us locations. See list of stores

2:16
Paris Baguette serves up sweet treats for Mother’s Day

Paris Baguette serves up sweet treats for Mother’s Day

1:34
The Real Deal: The best deals for mom this Mother’s Day

The Real Deal: The best deals for mom this Mother’s Day

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!