Ex-animal rescue president rejects animal cruelty plea deal; elects for bench trial

A former animal rescue president accused of starving five dogs to death has rejected a plea deal and instead will go to trial.

News 12 Staff

Oct 11, 2019, 6:40 PM

Updated 1,667 days ago

Share:

A former animal rescue president accused of starving five dogs to death has rejected a plea deal and instead will go to trial.
The state's offer called for Heidi Lueders to spend 2 ½ years in prison. It also would have allowed her to plead guilty to misdemeanor animal cruelty charges rather than felony animal cruelty charges, which she's currently facing.
In court Friday, she waived her right to a jury trial and requested a trial by judge.
Lueders is the former head of Bully Breed Rescue, which has since dissolved.
Last November, police found the skeletal remains of five pit bulls in her home in Fairfield. Each dog was still in its cage with a collar still on.
The case led to outrage around the area and beyond, with the community naming the dogs the “Fairfield Five.”

An attorney was appointed as an animal advocate for the dogs in court. Attorney Ken Bernhard told News 12 that he believed the state’s plea offer to be fair.
“If I were her, I would've taken it,” says Bernhard. “I think the difference between looking at a felony conviction and having the guarantee of a misdemeanor on my record in the long term would've been better."
Lueders’ attorney Rob Serafinowicz says the court-side trial is the “best option that we had with what we were presented with.”
Animal advocates told News 12 they were happy she rejected the plea and hope she’s convicted on the felony charges.
Her trial is expected to begin next year.
Along with the animal cruelty charges, Lueders faces a felony charge of criminal damage to a landlord's property by a tenant. Police say the home she was living in was filled with garbage, animal feces and drug paraphernalia.
 


More from News 12
0:51
Teen accused of driving stolen car while high, causing fatal crash in Centereach

Teen accused of driving stolen car while high, causing fatal crash in Centereach

1:38
Steady rain, chilly Sunday on Long Island; warmer start to workweek

Steady rain, chilly Sunday on Long Island; warmer start to workweek

0:23
Suffolk police: Pedestrian struck, killed by car in Copiague

Suffolk police: Pedestrian struck, killed by car in Copiague

0:50
Hundreds of athletes compete in Special Olympics New York Spring Games at Plainedge High School

Hundreds of athletes compete in Special Olympics New York Spring Games at Plainedge High School

0:24
Police: Huntington Station man critically injured in Dix Hills hit-and-run

Police: Huntington Station man critically injured in Dix Hills hit-and-run

0:27
Nassau police: 6 injured in shooting at Westbury home

Nassau police: 6 injured in shooting at Westbury home

0:21
State police: 32-year-old man killed in Wantagh Parkway crash

State police: 32-year-old man killed in Wantagh Parkway crash

0:45
Fire breaks out at Plainview storage facility

Fire breaks out at Plainview storage facility

1:50
‘No one is helping.’ Freeport tenants say complaints about fire alarm are falling on deaf ears

‘No one is helping.’ Freeport tenants say complaints about fire alarm are falling on deaf ears

0:46
Teachers participate at 15th annual 'GC for a Cure' 5K Run and Walk in memory of late educator

Teachers participate at 15th annual 'GC for a Cure' 5K Run and Walk in memory of late educator

0:53
Prosecutors: Queens man stole used cooking oil from 16 restaurants

Prosecutors: Queens man stole used cooking oil from 16 restaurants

0:28
Sag Harbor teen charged with DWI following crash into tree

Sag Harbor teen charged with DWI following crash into tree

2:15
Meeting held over next steps for cleanup at Bethpage Community Park

Meeting held over next steps for cleanup at Bethpage Community Park

1:32
Knowing the early warning signs during Stroke Awareness Month

Knowing the early warning signs during Stroke Awareness Month

0:38
Sam Ash Music announces closure of all store locations

Sam Ash Music announces closure of all store locations

1:39
Runners are lacing up for the Long Island Marathon Sunday. Click here to see which roads will close to traffic

Runners are lacing up for the Long Island Marathon Sunday. Click here to see which roads will close to traffic

1:58
Kids get up-close-and personal tour of Suffolk police headquarters during Police Week

Kids get up-close-and personal tour of Suffolk police headquarters during Police Week

2:15
EXCLUSIVE: Gov. Hochul talks retail theft, bail reform during visit to Lindenhurst

EXCLUSIVE: Gov. Hochul talks retail theft, bail reform during visit to Lindenhurst

1:56
JAC Shack gives BOCES students chance to work at restaurant

JAC Shack gives BOCES students chance to work at restaurant

2:39
Deer Park man heads to Washington DC to raise awareness about Alzheimer's disease

Deer Park man heads to Washington DC to raise awareness about Alzheimer's disease