Caterer abruptly closes, leaving customers in the lurch

<p>The Carlyle at the Palace in Plainview abruptly shut its doors, leaving dozens of customers scrambling to find other catering halls.</p>

News 12 Staff

Sep 21, 2018, 9:20 PM

Updated 2,057 days ago

Share:

The Carlyle at the Palace in Plainview abruptly shut its doors, leaving dozens of customers scrambling to find other catering halls.
The building is owned by the Nassau OTB. Nassau Regional OTB head Joe Cairo says the catering company's owner, Steve Carl, had leased the hall for about 10 years but recently fell behind on rent.
"As recently as a week ago, I think it was last Wednesday or Thursday, he was here with his attorney and indicated to us that he would be able to meet all of his obligations through the end of the year," says Cairo. "Monday came, Tuesday and late Tuesday afternoon, somewhere around 4:30, we got an email saying 'I'm out of business.'"
The landlord says they reached out to everyone who's booked an event after they found out the catering company fired all of its employees and shut down.
"It's almost like a moral thing to try to help these people," says Cairo.
The OTB reached out to several caterers who offered to help. Of the 70 events scheduled there through March, 20 are back on track.
Robyn Clemens, of East Northport, is among the dozens trying to find other catering halls for their special days.
"She shouldn't have to worry about where she's going to have her bat mitzvah after working five years for this major religious event in her life," says Clemens. "I'm angry. I'm upset. I've been crying all day. I was crying yesterday. I'm upset. My daughter's upset. She's 12 years old."
News 12 reached out to Carl's lawyer to ask about deposits, but they said they had no comment.
"I don't make that much," says Clemens. "I can't afford to just throw away $12,000 and then do it all over again somewhere else."


More from News 12
Police: Huntington Station pastor arrested for sexually abusing 15-year-old girl

Police: Huntington Station pastor arrested for sexually abusing 15-year-old girl

2:35
Showers likely today with highs near 68; some rain expected this weekend

Showers likely today with highs near 68; some rain expected this weekend

1:03
State DEC: Another concrete block found buried at Bethpage Community Park

State DEC: Another concrete block found buried at Bethpage Community Park

2:00
Deputy chief instructor at Nassau Fire Service Academy sustains burns during training exercise

Deputy chief instructor at Nassau Fire Service Academy sustains burns during training exercise

0:21
Animal advocatess: 9 guinea pigs rescued in East Setauket

Animal advocatess: 9 guinea pigs rescued in East Setauket

0:18
Police: 4 injured after car crashes into Central Islip home

Police: 4 injured after car crashes into Central Islip home

2:36
Long Islanders encouraged to donate nonperishable food to Stamp Out Hunger

Long Islanders encouraged to donate nonperishable food to Stamp Out Hunger

1:28
Northport-East Northport Board of Ed meeting to discuss finalized budget; 1st meeting since teen's arrest for threat

Northport-East Northport Board of Ed meeting to discuss finalized budget; 1st meeting since teen's arrest for threat

0:17
Police: Bellport gas station employee arrested for selling e-cigarette to minor

Police: Bellport gas station employee arrested for selling e-cigarette to minor

1:48
Plant lovers flock to Farmingdale State College for annual plant sale

Plant lovers flock to Farmingdale State College for annual plant sale

1:13
The East End: Sag Harbor Honey

The East End: Sag Harbor Honey

2:16
Get a sweet treat with the family at Sydney’s Sweets in West Hempstead

Get a sweet treat with the family at Sydney’s Sweets in West Hempstead

1:45
Fundraiser for Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island held at Crest Hollow Country Club in Woodbury

Fundraiser for Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island held at Crest Hollow Country Club in Woodbury

How to report anti-Asian hate crimes in the tri-state

How to report anti-Asian hate crimes in the tri-state

1:42
Town gives Family Service League 45 days to shut down West Babylon homeless shelter

Town gives Family Service League 45 days to shut down West Babylon homeless shelter

1:38
Navy officials say Bethpage plume is moving about a foot a day

Navy officials say Bethpage plume is moving about a foot a day

2:47
Suffolk law enforcement works with Amazon to prevent illegal contraband from getting into county jail

Suffolk law enforcement works with Amazon to prevent illegal contraband from getting into county jail

0:15
20-year-old man accused of breaking into home in Riverhead

20-year-old man accused of breaking into home in Riverhead

2:09
Exclusive look at field and stadium built for Cricket World Cup at Eisenhower Park

Exclusive look at field and stadium built for Cricket World Cup at Eisenhower Park

2:27
Huntington Town Board hosts second public hearing on walkable downtown in Melville

Huntington Town Board hosts second public hearing on walkable downtown in Melville