Attorney for Thomas Murphy held in contempt of court

The defense attorney for the man convicted of driving drunk and killing a 12-year-old Boy Scout was held in contempt of court Wednesday during a hearing.

News 12 Staff

Sep 16, 2020, 9:35 PM

Updated 1,314 days ago

Share:

The defense attorney for the man convicted of driving drunk and killing a 12-year-old Boy Scout was held in contempt of court Wednesday during a hearing.
The hearing involves the case of Thomas Murphy, who was convicted in December of driving drunk and then hitting a group of Boy Scouts in Manorville, killing Andrew McMorris.
News 12's Shari Einhorn reports that attorney Steven Politi was confrontational with the judge for two hours and was almost handcuffed. He now faces a $1,000 fine.
Politi argued that he wasn't able to properly do his job after one of his key witnesses wasn't allowed into the courthouse because he had been in contact with a family member who is now in quarantine. The judge instead insisted Politi call one of the many other witnesses who had been subpoenaed, and he refused.
Murphy's sentencing had already been pushed back several times because of the COVID-19 pandemic. When he was set to be sentenced last month, the defense filed a motion to have the guilty verdict thrown out.
Politi said new witnesses surfaced who saw the boys dangerously walking in the road. The defense also alleges jury misconduct, claiming the case was discussed outside of deliberations and that jurors read news reports about it.
On the stand, one juror and two alternate jurors testified that there were comments and statements made about witness testimony when the jury was not deliberating. There was also testimony that during the trial, one juror shared with the rest of the group information he had read in a newspaper.
"I feel awful for the victim's parents. I feel awful for the little boy, but that doesn't affect my job," says Politi. "I have a job to do and it's to represent Mr. Murphy and make sure he gets a fair trial."
If Murphy's conviction holds, he faces a maximum sentence of 25 years behind bars.
Alisa McMorris says her family has been devastated that the man convicted of killing their 12-year-old son two years ago still hasn't been sentenced.
"This is a terrible display of what should have ended years ago. Years – we're in years now. It'll be two years. It's a shame," says Alisa McMorris.
"They have compounded that trauma that we go through every single day. Compound it doublefold. They compound it day after day after day. And it's cruel and it's senseless and it's evil," says John McMorris, Andrew's father.


More from News 12
1:57
3 families displaced by fast-moving fire at North Amityville home

3 families displaced by fast-moving fire at North Amityville home

2:02
Sunny and mild Tuesday before rain returns Wednesday

Sunny and mild Tuesday before rain returns Wednesday

2:53
Sachem schools consider staffing and program cuts, piercing tax cap as budget vote looms

Sachem schools consider staffing and program cuts, piercing tax cap as budget vote looms

0:29
Jericho named Long Island's top rated high school by U.S. News and World Report

Jericho named Long Island's top rated high school by U.S. News and World Report

0:51
NCC working with food truck vendors to provide food for rest of semester

NCC working with food truck vendors to provide food for rest of semester

0:26
USDA warns of ground beef that may be contaminated with E.coli

USDA warns of ground beef that may be contaminated with E.coli

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

Is your mom awesome? Long Island tell us why your Mom Rocks!

1:42
Made on Long Island: Nicolock Paving Stones in Lindenhurst

Made on Long Island: Nicolock Paving Stones in Lindenhurst

0:48
9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

9 steps to take if your ‘fur-ever’ friend goes missing

0:51
State police: Trooper struck in the face by combative driver during Southern State Parkway traffic stop

State police: Trooper struck in the face by combative driver during Southern State Parkway traffic stop

1:54
Ronkonkoma woman pleads not guilty to 49 counts of animal cruelty

Ronkonkoma woman pleads not guilty to 49 counts of animal cruelty

1:33
Hampton Bays woman retrieves phone, wallet she accidently dumped into recycling bin nearly 3 weeks ago

Hampton Bays woman retrieves phone, wallet she accidently dumped into recycling bin nearly 3 weeks ago

1:55
Long Islanders taught about dangers of toxic pollutants in drinking water

Long Islanders taught about dangers of toxic pollutants in drinking water

0:16
Police: Long Beach man punched nurse in abdomen at Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital

Police: Long Beach man punched nurse in abdomen at Mount Sinai South Nassau Hospital

1:59
Long Island gets introduced to matzah pizza; proceeds will go toward charities

Long Island gets introduced to matzah pizza; proceeds will go toward charities

0:32
Spartans chosen as new mascot for Brentwood school district

Spartans chosen as new mascot for Brentwood school district

0:19
Police: 2 people hospitalized following Lawrence crash

Police: 2 people hospitalized following Lawrence crash

2:12
Amityville schools to receive $2 million from new state budget to help reduce budget deficit, save jobs

Amityville schools to receive $2 million from new state budget to help reduce budget deficit, save jobs

0:17
Man wanted for stealing $1,000 in merchandise from Centereach store

Man wanted for stealing $1,000 in merchandise from Centereach store

0:48
Nonprofit environmental group hosts discussion on climate change at Jones Beach event

Nonprofit environmental group hosts discussion on climate change at Jones Beach event